Key points first

The Commitments of Traders report shows once a week how reportable traders are positioned in futures; what stands behind a single position, it does not show. Because of the delay of a few days, it suits swing trading best. Classic indicators such as net positioning and the COT index look at each group on its own; positioning can be more meaningful in relation to total open interest and to the number of traders, combined with a chart-based entry logic.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 19

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: ATAS DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

What the CoT report is

CoT stands for Commitments of Traders. The report of the US agency CFTC shows how traders are positioned in a futures market. When a trader exceeds the reporting threshold the CFTC sets for a market, their positions are reported to the CFTC through reporting firms such as clearing members and brokers. Most of the futures private traders work with are listed at the CME. The reference date for the reported positions is always the Tuesday; on the following Friday the CFTC publishes the report. It is publicly available on the CFTC website.

The delay of a few days is only of limited help for day trading, even though there are individual use cases. For swing trading, it barely matters, especially since the data usually changes only a little from one week to the next. That is why CoT dataThe weekly positioning data of the Commitments of Traders report of the US agency CFTC on futures markets. is mainly a tool for swing traders.

You can also read how CoT data is used in swing trading in general in our article COT Data in Trading: How to Read Positioning.

03

The trader groups in the report

The CFTC provides the report in various formats, including comma-separated for evaluation in Excel. There are two report types: the classic legacy report and the more modern disaggregated report. Each comes as “Futures Only” and as “Futures-and-Options Combined”; private traders mostly use the futures-only version. The table shows how the trader groups differ.

CriterionLegacy report (classic)Disaggregated report
Reportable: commercial / hedgingCommercialsProducer/Merchant/Processor/User (one category, roughly equivalent to the commercials)
Reportable: swap businessNot shown separately, generally included in the commercialsSwap dealers
Reportable: speculationNon-commercialsManaged money
Reportable: otherNot shown separately, mostly included in the non-commercialsOther reportables
Not reportableNonreportable positions: one combined residual (total open interest minus reportable positions), individual traders not shownNonreportable positions: one combined residual (total open interest minus reportable positions), individual traders not shown

In the legacy report, commercialsTraders who, by CFTC classification, use futures for hedging in connection with their business, such as producers and processors of a commodity. are traders who, by CFTC classification, use futures to hedge in connection with their business, such as coffee farmers as producers and processors as buyers. The non-commercialsReportable traders who are not classified as commercial, typically funds and other speculators. are reportable traders who are not classified as commercial, typically funds and other speculators who bet on the price movement. All positions below the reporting threshold end up in the nonreportable positions, which include most private traders.

The disaggregated report knows four reportable categories. The swap dealers are a special case: a swap dealer, for example, secures a wheat farmer a price off the exchange and speculates that the wheat price will rise. If the risk becomes too large for them, they hedge on the futures exchange. In the indicator view, this looks similar to the commercials, while the way of thinking is closer to that of the speculators; that is why the swap dealers are filtered out in the analysis shown in the webinar. The managed moneyAsset managers such as CTAs, CPOs and funds that trade futures for clients (CFTC definition). In the disaggregated report, comparable to the non-commercials in the legacy report. category covers asset managers and funds, in other words the large speculators. The other reportables are everyone who does not fit into any other category.

The report also shows how many traders per category hold a position (the number of traders). Meant are the reportable traders per category, often companies or funds. This figure is easily overlooked. Three figures are at the center: total open interestThe number of open futures contracts in a market. It rises when new contracts are created and falls when existing ones are closed; trading volume, by contrast, counts every transaction., the positioning of the commercials and that of the large speculators.

04

Which group matters most today

Ten years ago, when the topic came up in Germany, producers were seen as the group to watch first. The logic behind it: a coffee farmer sees the weather and the plants and is best placed to judge whether the price is fair.

Commercials use the futures markets in the classic way for hedgingProtection against price fluctuations, for example by buying or selling futures.. When the price falls, processors buy futures because the commodity is cheap. When it rises, producers sell futures because the price becomes attractive. Both thus stand against the trend movement. This role has shifted: market participants among the commercials now speculate as well, which makes their behavior less clear to private traders than it used to be.

With the non-commercials, the business model is clearer: they want to profit from price movements, backed by their own analysis departments. What stands behind a single position, however, the report does not show, because the CFTC assigns traders to a category by their predominant business. That this group judges the markets correctly most often is an assessment: “It can now be evaluated statistically that the non-commercials, the large speculators, are right most often in their assessment of the markets. Their intention is always clearly set,” says Oliver Sparing. His main focus is therefore on the non-commercials, in the disaggregated report on the managed money; with them he develops his fundamental bias.

05

Liquidity and the warning sign

The native CoT indicator in ATAS shows the net positions, using gold as the example: green for the large speculators, red for the commercials. Normally, the lines run toward each other in a funnel shape. When the price falls, the large speculators build short positions and the commercials buy.

Daily chart of the gold future with the ATAS indicator COT Net positions: green, blue and red lines for large speculators, small traders and commercials
Visible: daily chart of the gold future (GC, COMEX), below it the ATAS indicator “COT Net positions” from the legacy report: green line large speculators (non-commercials), blue line small traders, red line commercials. Green and red mostly run against each other. In Oliver's reading, speculators and hedgers thus form each other's counterparty. From minute 18:08. Image: ATAS Deutschland

The CoT report shows positioning, not directly the liquidity in the market. liquidityThe supply of prices and counterparties in the market. Where buyers and sellers each find a counterparty, the price stays more stable. can be derived from it: if speculators and hedgers each form the counterparty to the other, that keeps markets stable. A marketplace makes the idea tangible. If 50 vendors sell eggs there, the price stays stable. If only one vendor still has eggs, they can drive the price as they please. The price is determined first and foremost by supply and demand in the cash markets; the futures markets offer hedging options and can help keep prices stable.

This gives rise to a possible warning sign. Oliver Sparing puts it this way: “If both suddenly start trading in the same direction, it gets critical, whether up or down, in stock markets of course mainly down. If speculators and hedgers alike stand out through selling, the market lacks liquidity.” The time in early 2020, when Covid emerged, is worth a look. For stock indices such as the S&P 500, the informative value of CoT data is considered lower than in commodities; as a look at the health of the market, it can still be useful. In day trading and swing trading alike, liquidity stays in view.

06

Classic indicators: net positioning and the COT index

The best-known indicators are net positioningLong positions minus short positions of a trader group as an absolute value. and the COT indexAn indicator by Larry Williams that normalizes net positioning to the highest and lowest value of a period and outputs it in percent.. Net positioning subtracts the short positions from the long positions of a trader group. When the line rises, more was bought than sold in that week. It stays within the respective group and does not put it in relation to others. It shows mainly whether positioning is rising or falling. Indirectly, it can also give a hint about the liquidity of the market.

The COT index goes back to Larry Williams. It normalizes the net positioning of a group to the highest and lowest value of a period, for example 52 weeks, and states in percent where the group currently stands in between. Values near 0 or 100 are classically read as an oversold or overbought range. In the gold example, the index fell below 20 in March 2022, and the market turned. Elsewhere, it ran considerably further after an extreme value.

Gold daily chart with net positions and, below, the COT index from 0 to 100; the mouse pointer marks a value in the lower range below 20
Visible: gold daily chart, below it the net positions, at the bottom the COT index (0 to 100) with dashed lines marking the upper and lower range. The mouse pointer marks an index value below 20, around March 9, 2022 according to Oliver. The gold price is at a high there and falls clearly afterwards. Interpretation: an extreme value can accompany a turn, but it does not trigger one. That the market can also keep running after an extreme value, Oliver shows elsewhere in the same chart. From minute 38:05. Image: ATAS Deutschland

These indicators have aged. In Oliver's observation, they no longer work as well as they did 15, 20 or 30 years ago. As basic knowledge about CoT data, the literature on it, for example by Larry Williams, is still considered worth reading.

07

Open interest and volume

Two terms are often confused: volume counts every transaction, open interest counts the open contracts. An example from the webinar: a buyer buys a futures contract from a seller. Now there is one contract, so open interest stands at 1, and one transaction, so volume also stands at 1. If the buyer sells the contract on to a new buyer, there are two transactions, and volume rises to 2. But there is still only one contract, so open interest stays at 1.

How open interest changes depends on whether the parties open or close positions. If both sides open new positions, it rises by one contract. If one side opens and the other closes, it stays the same, as in the example with the second buyer. If both close, it falls. Open interest therefore shows the trading interest in a market. That lets you assess whether a price move comes from new positions or from market participants taking profits.

08

Two weaknesses and your own evaluation

Two weaknesses stand out in the classic indicators. First, they look at one group on its own. If the net long open interest of the commercials rises, that is less meaningful when the total open interest of the market grows much faster in parallel. Seen in relation to the overall market, positioning becomes more meaningful.

Second, they refer only to open interest and not to the number of traders holding a position. An extremely high open interest that only three or four out of 200 traders hold says something different from one that almost all available traders have built.

That is why Oliver Sparing first built his own Excel spreadsheets with his own algorithms, into which he entered the positioning of the managed money and the commercials every weekend. The evaluation cost him three to five hours each weekend. Later, together with a programmer from the swing trading programme, software emerged that runs this evaluation every week: the TradeNeon software, today Futures Insights.

In one chart of the TradeNeon software, open interest is plotted against the number of traders. The y-axis shows open interest, the x-axis the number of traders who hold it. A historical point cloud emerges: fainter dots lie further back, and the large white dot is the current report. In the gold example shown (managed money long, as of July 23, 2024), 105 traders hold long positions with an open interest of 197,802 contracts; the dot sits in the upper middle of the cloud. As a thought experiment, the extreme case at the top right can be played through: if the price rises while the current report sits there, many traders are already historically high long, and it is hard to say who is left to buy. Oliver Sparing himself calls this back-of-the-envelope math, but has found such situations valuable in practice. Extremes can, however, build up further, so caution is needed.

TradeNeon software with two point clouds for managed money long and short in gold; a large white dot marks the current report
Visible: TradeNeon software (then tradeneon.app), gold, two point clouds “Dry Powder MML” (managed money long, turquoise) and “Dry Powder MMS” (managed money short, pink). The y-axis shows open interest, the x-axis the number of traders; fainter dots lie further back in time, the large white dot is the current report. The tooltip on the left gives the status of July 23, 2024: 105 traders with long positions, open interest long 197,802 contracts. The white dot sits in the upper middle of the cloud, not in the extreme range at the top right; Oliver describes that extreme case as a thought experiment. From minute 55:53. Image: ATAS Deutschland
09

Why extreme values are not a trigger

What an extreme value says shows in the example of the commercials' short positions. When this value falls to a historically low level, the producers evidently no longer sell because the price is too low for them. That is useful information, and a private trader can wait for the price to turn.

This is exactly where the catch lies. When it is said that CoT data no longer works, that can also come down to how it is applied: an extreme value does not mean you buy or sell right away. In the gold example, the price keeps rising although the indicator outputs ever more extreme values.

Fundamental data such as CoT, seasonality and term structure are therefore something you combine with a chart-based logic to find entries. That takes an understanding of market logic and of auction and price formation processes. VWAP, volume profile, price action and technical analysis are options for entries. For swing trading, fundamental data such as CoT is a tool for checking the starting point before you think about buying or selling.

10

How the large speculators trade

Oliver Sparing describes the behavior of the large speculators like this: “The large speculators start extending their short positions in downward moves. The further the market falls, the more short they are. When the price turns and starts to rise, they start building their long positions, and the further the market rises, the more they buy.” Private traders often do the opposite: they see a falling market, think it can hardly go lower, buy and watch it keep falling.

He states the consequence like this: “If you want to make money in the markets, trade like the large speculators and not the other way around. You want to buy into rising prices and sell into falling ones, and you never want to be the hero who catches the absolute low of a move.” For Oliver Sparing, this is the most important message of the webinar.

11

What you can take away from the webinar

  • The CoT report is a swing trading tool. The data appears weekly and usually changes slowly. For short-term trading, it helps only to a limited extent.
  • The first look goes to the non-commercials. In the disaggregated report that is the managed money; with them, a fundamental bias can be developed. What stands behind a single position, the report does not show.
  • Positioning needs context. Put it in relation to total open interest and to the number of traders holding a position.
  • An extreme value is not yet an entry. Combine the data with a chart-based logic and an understanding of market logic.

“Just because this data has reached an extreme value does not mean we wildly click on buy or sell.”

Oliver Sparing in the ATAS webinar (translated from German)
12

About the webinar

The webinar ran on August 1, 2024 as part of the ATAS Deutschland webinar series on the YouTube channel of ATAS Deutschland. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on machine-translated subtitles. ATAS is a trading platform for order flow analysis. Oliver is a regular guest there; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Note: the video is a recording from 2024. Brand and company names in the video reflect the status at that time.

Free Plan · Futures Insights
CoT data in relation to the overall market
Futures Insights calculates three fundamentals, including CoT data, and presents them in five indicators. In the Free Plan, you can view gold (GC) with all indicators.
Start Free Plan
Frequently asked questions
What is the CoT report and when is it published?

CoT stands for Commitments of Traders. When a trader in a futures market exceeds the reporting threshold set by the CFTC, their positions are reported to the US agency CFTC through reporting firms such as clearing members and brokers. The reference date for the reported positions is always the Tuesday; on the following Friday the CFTC publishes the report. It is publicly available on the CFTC website.

Is CoT data also useful for day trading?

Only to a limited extent. The data counts mainly as a tool for swing trading, because the delay of a few days barely matters there and the values usually change only a little from week to week. The liquidity of the market stays in view anyway.

Which trader group is at the center?

Often the non-commercials, in the disaggregated report the managed money. Their business model is clearer: they want to profit from price movements. What stands behind a single position, the report does not show, because the CFTC assigns traders to a category by their predominant business. With the commercials, the picture is less sharp, because market participants speculate there too.

Why is an extreme value in the CoT report not enough for a trade?

An extreme value can build up further, and the price often keeps running anyway. The data is therefore combined with a chart-based entry logic and an understanding of market logic, instead of buying or selling right away at an extreme.

What is the difference between open interest and volume?

Volume counts every transaction, open interest counts the open contracts. If a buyer sells the contract on to a new buyer, volume rises to 2 while open interest stays at 1. If both sides open new positions, open interest rises; if both close, it falls.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances