
Should I buy Gold and precious metals physically or through an exchange?
There are different ways to buy gold and other precious metals. This comparison examines physical holdings and exchange products: costs, custody, risks and differences in tax treatment.
Image: TradeNeon
Is investing in precious metals worthwhile?
Gold and silver have a long history as stores of value and means of payment
Gold and silver have been used as stores of value and means of payment for a long time. This does not guarantee investment success today. Whether precious metals fit your portfolioThe portfolio is the collective term for all assets owned by a client, a company or an investment fund. depends on your objective, time horizon, capacity for losses and existing investments. Some investors use gold for diversificationThe term diversification refers to the spreading, or allocation of assets across different investment types, industries or economic regions. or as a reserve. Its price can still fall; neither reliable protection against inflation nor a particular return is promised. Compare an investment in metal with alternatives on a consistent basis of risk, costs and returns.
What returns have precious metals delivered?
Returns on gold
Let us first consider returns. Gold’s performance depends on the period, currency and data series examined. Your investment also depends on the purchase price, subsequent selling price and trading, custody and insurance costs. Historical return figures require identifiable start and end dates and a clear calculation method. A price increase before costs is not your personal net return. Past price movements guarantee neither a future return nor reliable protection against inflation.
A comparison with stocks or rental property also needs matching periods, currency and comparable costs and income. The metal price alone, a stock index’s total return including dividends and a property’s rental yield are different measures. They do not establish that gold always performs better or worse in terms of returns and fluctuations. The following original graphic shows a historical period; it is not current market analysis.

Historical original graphic from the July 2021 article. It does not establish a complete 30-year return series or show the current gold price.
Returns on silver
Silver’s price follows a different path from gold’s and can fluctuate substantially over extended periods. An investor who buys at a high price may still face losses years later. Past returns alone do not establish that silver has better future prospects. A sound comparison requires defined periods, the same currency and traceable data. The graphic shows a historical period as presented in the July 2021 article. It establishes neither a complete 30-year return nor today’s distance from previous highs.

Historical silver-price graphic from the July 2021 article. The illustration and outlook from that time are neither a current price quote nor evidence of returns in 2026.
Gold and silver may complement a portfolio through diversification because their performance can differ from that of other asset classes. Whether this helps depends on the overall composition and period examined. Precious metals can also lose value; calling them a safe haven does not guarantee preservation of value in every crisis. A reserve of metal does not automatically replace readily available funds for ongoing expenses.
Returns on platinum and palladium
Platinum and palladium have industrial uses and their prices may also fluctuate substantially. Whether they are more volatile than gold or silver depends on the period and measurement method; no permanent ranking is established here. Beyond choosing a metal, consider which investment structure suits your purpose: physical goods, an exchange-traded security and a derivative have different costs and risks.
How are physical precious metals taxed in Germany?
Taxation of gold
For tax purposes, distinguish buying from subsequently selling. This section covers ordinarily held physical precious metals in private assets in Germany, as of 6 October 2026. Investment gold is exempt from VAT under the conditions of section 25c of the German VAT Act(UStG). This applies to legally defined bars, wafers and coins, not indiscriminately to every gold product, piece of jewellery or collector’s offer. Income tax on a possible later sale gain is a separate question. Commercial trading, special income-generating arrangements or residence in another country may require different treatment.
What qualifies as investment gold?
Bars or wafers must have a weight accepted by the bullion markets and a purity of at least 995 thousandths.
Gold coins must have a purity of at least 900 thousandths, have been minted after 1800, and be or have been legal tender in their country of origin.
These coins must also usually sell at a price that exceeds the open-market value of their gold content by no more than 80 percent.
These conditions apply together. The description gold or investment coin does not replace checking the actual product.
A later private sale
For ordinarily held physical precious metals, section 23 of Germany’s Income Tax Act(EStG) generally applies. If no more than one year passes between purchase and sale, a gain may be taxable at your personal income-tax rate. After more than one year, such an ordinary sale generally falls outside this one-year period. If the asset was used to generate ongoing income, possible special rules require separate examination.
The total gain from private disposals is tax-free if it is less than EUR 1,000 in the calendar year. This is an exemption threshold, not a deductible allowance: once the threshold is reached, the ordinarily taxable entire gain is subject to tax, rather than only its excess. Other private disposals in the same year may count towards it. Relevant factors include purchase and selling prices and eligible costs; keep the records.
These rules are not a general tax exemption for ETCs, futuresA future is a standardized forward contract that obligates the trading partners to a transaction in the future. or options. Examine their product structures and applicable income-tax rules separately.
In Germany, cash purchases of precious metals generally trigger statutory due-diligence and identification obligations for goods dealers from EUR 2,000. An amount below this threshold does not guarantee anonymity; suspicious transactions, for example, can trigger obligations regardless of value. Related actions must be considered together as a transaction. This cash threshold is not a tax allowance. It establishes neither a general family exemption nor a reliable way around identification by splitting purchases over time.
Taxation of silver
Silver has no general VAT exemption equivalent to investment gold. An ordinary dealer sale of silver bars or investment coins under standard taxation in Germany generally attracts 19 percent VAT. For certain coins and eligible acquisition routes, a reseller may apply the margin scheme: VAT is then calculated on the reseller’s margin and remains included in the price. This does not make silver tax-free for the buyer.
The margin scheme has specific conditions
Section 25 a UStG requires, among other conditions, a reseller and an eligible acquisition chain: within the EU, the goods must have been supplied under one of the tax arrangements specified by law. Certain raw forms of precious metals are explicitly excluded by their customs classification. For coins, the actual tax and customs classification matters. An eligible case may involve acquiring a suitable coin from a private seller; this is not a rule for every silver coin or import.
Check which tax treatment the dealer applies to the specific offer and the stated final and repurchase prices. Do not compare offers solely by the phrase margin taxed.
In ordinary sales of silver bars under standard taxation in Germany, the general 19 percent VAT rate usually applies. This affects total costs but does not automatically make the product unsuitable for every private buyer. Compare purchase and repurchase prices, denominations, trading spreads, custody and insurance. A later private sale must be considered separately under the applicable income-tax rules.
The shape of a coin bar alone does not determine its VAT treatment. An imprinted face value or the description coin creates no blanket tax exemption and does not make every silver bar eligible for the margin scheme. The actual classification and statutory requirements for the tax treatment applied are decisive. Examine the dealer’s specific offer and final price rather than treating a coin bar as a universally tax-free solution.
Taxation of platinum and palladium
For ordinary physical platinum and palladium products sold under standard taxation in Germany,19 percent VAT generally forms part of the cost comparison. This establishes neither general unsuitability nor a universal 19 percent profit threshold. Your actual result reflects purchase price, subsequent proceeds, premiums and discounts, trading spreads, custody costs and price movements together. A later private sale is also considered separately under the applicable income-tax rules. Special products or acquisition circumstances require individual examination.
Tax is therefore one part of the assessment. A comparison between physical metal and an exchange product also involves price, trading spreads, recurring costs, custody, access and legal structure. Which differences matter most depends on your purpose. This brings us back to the question: what role should the investment fulfil?
What are the ways to invest in gold?
Buying gold investment coins
Consider a well-known gold investment coin: the Royal Canadian Mint’s Maple Leaf. It is offered as a bullion product. Compare its costs against gold content, denomination and the current offer. Collector-oriented coins may include additional price components; this does not establish a universal ranking of premiums across all coins and dealers.
Before a coin reaches a buyer, several services are needed, including extracting or recovering the metal, refining, minting, quality testing, transport and distribution. The Royal Canadian Mint describes refining and coin manufacturing among its own activities. The actual supply chain can vary; not every coin necessarily passes through the same banks, wholesalers or testing bodies. These services, together with supply and demand, may be reflected in the dealer’s price.

Premiums over the metal value vary by denomination, coin, dealer and market conditions. The original article’s historical calculation from July 2021 assumed a gold price of EUR 1,512 and a dealer price of EUR 1,562 per ounce. The EUR 50 difference is approximately 3.3 percent of the assumed metal price. The dealer quote cited at the time has not been independently reconfirmed here as reliable market evidence; the example is neither a current offer nor a return figure. For a comparison today, obtain an actual purchase quote and a simultaneous repurchase quote, including all costs.
Trading gold through brokers and certificates
Brokers offer different instruments linked to the gold price. A name such as Gold or XAU/USD alone does not tell you whether you are trading physical holdings, a CFD, a certificate or another product. Check the instrument, venue, pricing, costs, leverage, counterparty and protections applicable to you. Certificates are debt securities and may also trade on an exchange. Exchange trading does not eliminate issuer or market risk. A blanket claim that all prices are set exclusively by a broker or bank and never formed on an exchange is therefore inaccurate.
Trading gold through futures
A future provides another way to trade exposure to gold prices. CME’s Micro Gold future MGC represents 10 troy ounces, making it smaller than the 100-ounce gold contract. Its smaller size does not automatically suit every small account or establish consistently sufficient liquidity. Check contract value, tick value, margin, position size and loss and execution risks. Margin is collateral, not a general maximum loss. Margin-call obligations and customer protections depend on matters including the contract, client status and jurisdiction. Futures expire and have product-specific delivery and settlement rules. MGC has a physical settlement structure; brokers may impose earlier closing deadlines. To maintain market exposure beyond expiry, you can close a position in time and open a later contract. Rolling may incur trading costs and spreads; the futures curve and differences between contract prices also influence performance. A roll is not necessarily an immediate debit of a fixed roll loss. Derivatives therefore require different planning from a purely long-term metal reserve.
Trading gold through ETCs
ETCs(Exchange Traded Commodities) provide exchange-traded exposure to commodities. They are generally debt securities rather than fund units such as ETFs. Physically backed and derivative-based ETCs differ in price tracking, backing and risk structure. Read the key information document, prospectus and terms of the specific product. Physical backing is a relevant structural feature, but neither an overall ranking as best nor a guarantee of value. The suitable structure depends on your objective and the overall assessment.
ETCs also provide access to silver, platinum and palladium. Physical backing does not automatically make you the owner of specific bars. A debt security gives you the claims against the relevant entity set out in its terms. Whether delivery rights exist, who can exercise them, and applicable denominations, fees, deadlines and other conditions depend on the product. Take such a right seriously and examine it. Also check what backing the prospectus requires, how it is evidenced and what enforcement rights apply if problems arise.
ETCs involve issuer, market and product-structure risks. Physical backing may shape risks differently but does not automatically eliminate them. Collateral, ranking, custodian, enforcement rules and the extent of claims matter. In the iShares example examined, claims are limited to the relevant secured assets; if these are insufficient, claims may remain unpaid. This is a specific product structure, not a statement about every ETC. The consequences of insolvency depend on the structure and assets actually available. Assess these conditions alongside costs and the losses you can afford.
Gold ETCs do not all receive the same tax treatment
Tax treatment depends on the documented claims and specific product structure. In its decision of 16 June 2020, case VIII R 7/17 concerning Gold Bullion Securities, Germany’s Federal Fiscal Court did not classify gains under the conditions considered as an ordinary capital claim under section 20 EStG. Relevant factors included a claim primarily directed at physical gold delivery and the issuer’s obligation to use almost all supplied capital to acquire gold.
This product-specific case law may make section 23 EStG relevant. It does not promise the one-year rule or tax exemption for every physically backed ETC. Check the current terms and tax treatment of the specific security. Futures, options and CFD transactions are likewise not treated as ordinarily held physical gold solely because they reference gold; applicable derivatives rules may fall under section 20 EStG.
Physical gold versus ETCs
Advantages of physical precious metals
You can hold physical precious metals yourself; access then does not directly depend on a securities account. This does not protect against theft, loss, damage or price falls. Storage options include a suitable personal safe, a bank safe-deposit box or a specialist custodian. Compare security, insurance, access, contractual terms and costs. With third-party custody, also examine ownership and release claims. If you consider metal a crisis reserve, plan realistically how you can access it. Hiding it at home is not generally the best solution, and access to a safe-deposit box follows different conditions from a securities claim.
Advantages of ETCs
You can buy and sell ETCs through a securities account on the relevant trading venues. Execution depends on trading hours, market conditions and liquidity; access at any time at a specific price is not guaranteed. Compare order and venue charges, bid/ask spreads, product costs and account costs against dealer premiums, custody and insurance for physical metal. An ETC may cost less, but a comparison requires a specific product, amount and holding period. Market price and reported product value can differ. Product structure and currency movements also affect the result; trading a product in euros does not itself mean it is currency hedged. A metal-price increase does not automatically produce a profit after costs, and a falling price can cause losses.
This brings us back to the original question: what is your purpose?
Your purpose determines how to buy precious metals
Physical precious metals as a reserve for retirement or a potential crisis
If you want to hold gold or silver for many years as part of a reserve, physical ownership may have a role. Whether home storage, a safe-deposit box or a custodian suits you depends on security, access, insurance and costs. Premiums and trading spreads still matter over a long holding period. An isolated EUR 50 or EUR 100 amount is not enough to judge costs without considering metal quantity, investment amount and holding period. Reserve planning should also consider how you would actually sell when needed and which funds you need at short notice for other expenses.
ETCs for portfolio diversification
For frequent buying and selling, physical metals are often less practical because of trading spreads and handling. ETCs may offer an alternative in a securities account, but still require deliberate assessment of your objective, costs, risks and specific terms. A documented delivery claim is not merely non-binding paperwork: examine its scope, exercise conditions and costs for the product. Neither blanket reassurance nor a blanket dismissal of all delivery claims is accurate. What matters is the role the investment should play in your portfolio and the risks you can bear.
Active short-term trading in futures or futures options is a different approach from a purely long-term metal reserve. It requires knowledge of markets and products, a suitable loss budget and monitoring of positions and execution. Analysis tools help assess markets; they secure neither profits nor additional income.
Frequently asked questions
Is gold tax-free in Germany?
Only legally defined investment gold is exempt from VAT under section 25c UStG. A later private sale requires separate assessment: for ordinarily held physical precious metals, a sale after more than one year generally falls outside the one-year period of section 23 EStG. A gain within that period may be taxable. Under the stated conditions, private disposal gains remain tax-free if their total is less than EUR 1,000 in the calendar year. This is an exemption threshold, not a deductible allowance. Special cases may differ.
Can I buy precious metals anonymously with cash?
In Germany, precious-metal cash purchases generally trigger statutory due-diligence and identification duties for goods dealers from EUR 2,000. Suspicious transactions may trigger duties regardless of value, and related actions count together. A value below the threshold does not guarantee anonymity.
Is margin-taxed silver free of VAT?
No. An ordinary dealer sale under standard German taxation generally attracts 19 percent VAT. In an eligible margin-scheme transaction, VAT is calculated on the reseller’s margin and remains included in the price. Product classification and acquisition chain must satisfy section 25a UStG.
Do I own the bars in a physically backed ETC?
Not automatically. ETCs are generally debt securities. You hold the claims documented by the specific product. Check collateral, custody, ranking, enforcement rules and any delivery rights in its prospectus and terms. Physical backing does not universally eliminate market or issuer risks.
Does the one-year rule apply to every gold ETC?
No. The German Federal Fiscal Court’s 16 June 2020 judgment on Gold Bullion Securities concerned a specific structure with a claim primarily directed at physical gold delivery. It does not promise tax exemption for all physically backed ETCs. Examine the actual claims and applicable tax treatment.
Why are gold futures different from ordinary metal holdings?
Futures have a contract size, expiry and settlement rules. The Micro Gold future MGC represents 10 troy ounces and has a physical settlement structure. Margin is collateral, not a general loss limit. Longer exposure requires planning for deadlines, delivery rules, rolling and costs. A smaller contract alone does not establish suitability for every small account.
Can I try the gold market in the Futures Insights Free Plan?
Yes. The Gold (GC) market is included in the Futures Insights Free Plan with all indicators. Futures Insights 2.0 offers 26 markets in total for analysing further markets.
Sources and context
Editorial sources checked 6 October 2026. Historical data and views are identified by their respective periods.
- Investment gold: Definition and VAT exemptionGermany: section 25 c conditions; not an exemption for every gold product.
- Private disposals in GermanyGermany, ordinary private assets: more than one year and an annual gain strictly below EUR 1,000; special cases may differ.
- German VAT rateGermany: ordinary 19 percent rate; check product and acquisition exceptions.
- German VAT margin schemeReseller, acquisition-chain and customs conditions; no general exemption for silver coins.
- Anti-money-laundering due diligencePrecious-metal cash purchases from EUR 2,000; additional triggers possible; not a tax allowance.
- Related transactions under the German AML ActRelated actions may constitute one transaction.
- Capital income and derivatives transactionsGermany: derivatives do not automatically follow the metal holding-period rule.
- Federal Fiscal Court 16 June 2020: VIII R 7/17Product-specific Gold Bullion Securities judgment; no automatic application to all ETCs.
- Risks of gold and precious-metal investmentsCFTC: U.S. context on price, costs and leverage; U.S. authorisation rules and example prices not adopted here.
- Cost questions for physical precious metalsCFTC/FINRA: assess costs, repurchase and custody; no blanket storage recommendation.
- Maple Leaf and bullion productsRoyal Canadian Mint: investment-coin context; no universal premium ranking.
- Refining and manufacturing servicesRoyal Canadian Mint: production services; no universal supply chain.
- Micro Gold FuturesCME:10 troy ounces and settlement structure; no automatic suitability or liquidity guarantee.
- Futures expiry and rollingCME: expiry and rolling; examine actual broker deadlines separately.
- Futures curves: Contango and backwardationCME: contract and spot-price relationships; no fixed roll-loss debit.
- Futures marginCME: collateral and exposure; historical examples are not current margin requirements.
- Order types and executionCME: limit, stop and execution rules; no guaranteed maximum stop loss.
- Xetra-Gold product termsProduct-specific legal and delivery structure; no general ETC guarantee.
- iShares Physical Gold ETCProduct-specific limited-recourse, collateral and market-price structure; no recommendation or guarantee.
- Exchange trading of certificatesDeutsche Börse: exchange trading does not imply general product safety.
You may also be interested in
The content of this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell. Trading and investing in the financial markets involve considerable risk, up to and including the total loss of capital. You make your own decisions and are responsible for them.
© 2026 TradeNeon FZCO. All rights reserved.