Exit During a Drawdown? What the Backtest Shows

Exit During a Drawdown? What the Backtest Shows

A person studies a descending metallic path that continues through a dark space.
TradingRisk management

Exit during a drawdown?
What the backtest shows

Exit during a drawdown—or stay with the system? Oliver Sparing and Sven Otremba discuss what a trading pause changed in a historical backtest.

An exit changes the path to a possible return.Image: TradeNeon

A falling equity curve can make closing positions and waiting for a new high feel sensible. Oliver Sparing and Sven Otremba discuss how traders deal with such periods in the Trading Podcast. Sven tested an exit rule using the Equity Growth System in TradeNeon's Titan module. The comparison describes what happened under that rule in the historical test; it cannot predict the next drawdown.

Basis for every figure below: historical Equity Growth System backtestIn a backtest, a trading strategy is applied to historical price data to check how it would have performed in the past. using daily data from 3 January 2000 to 8 September 2026; Sven's analysis dated 13 September 2026. The results are hypothetical, not actual trading results. Past backtests are not reliable indicators of future results. Trading stocks can result in the loss of invested capital.

01

Which exit rule did Sven test?

A drawdown is the decline of an equity curve from its most recent high. In Sven's calculation, a follower initially mirrors the model portfolio. If that portfolio's curve falls five or ten percent below its previous high, the follower closes all positions that day and holds cash. Trading resumes only when the model portfolio reaches a new high.

This is not a stop-loss on an individual trade. It is an additional rule for the whole account. The model portfolio continues trading during the pause; the follower's account does not participate in any recovery. Once the curves diverge, a five-percent trigger on the model portfolio cannot guarantee a five-percent loss limit in the follower's account.

Sven compared the variants using the same daily returns as the original backtest. This is a historical rule test. It does not reproduce a particular follower's execution, different fill prices (slippageSlippage is the difference between the expected execution price of an order and the price at which it is actually filled.) or missed trades as a personal account statement.

02

What changed in the backtest?

The three Equity Growth System sizes differ in their strategies, stock universes and maximum number of simultaneous positions. For each size, Sven compared continuous participation with pauses triggered at five and ten percent.

Sven's comparison · historical backtest
How a pause changes the curve
ContinuousPause at 10 %Pause at 5 %
Historical EGS equity curves, Size SLogarithmic scale. Three sets of sampled points from Sven's curves: continuous participation, pause at ten percent and pause at five percent, 2000 to 2026. Final values: 306.8, 67.0 and 15.1 times the starting value.125102050100200500200020052010201520202025Continuous: Final value 306.8 times the starting valuePause at 10 %: Final value 67.0 times the starting valuePause at 5 %: Final value 15.1 times the starting value
Continuous: 306.8×Pause at 10 %: 67.0×Pause at 5 %: 15.1×
Indexed equity curve, logarithmic scale. Half-year points and the final weekly point are sampled from Sven's weekly curves; straight lines between them do not show every fluctuation. Daily backtest: 3 January 2000 to 8 September 2026; final weekly label: 11 September 2026. Source: Sven Otremba, analysis dated 13 September 2026. Hypothetical results, not a forecast.

Historical backtest: 3 January 2000 to 8 September 2026; analysis: 13 September 2026. Annualised return and deepest drawdown refer to the full simulated curve of each variant.

Size Measure Continuous Pause at 5% Pause at 10%
S Annualised backtest return 23.9% 10.7% 17.1%
S Deepest backtest drawdown −17.9% −19.8% −16.3%
M Annualised backtest return 25.5% 11.8% 19.6%
M Deepest backtest drawdown −19.4% −18.0% −16.6%
L Annualised backtest return 26.8% 12.4% 20.4%
L Deepest backtest drawdown −18.3% −20.4% −14.6%

With the five-percent rule, annualised backtest returns fell to less than half for all three sizes. The deepest drawdown became larger for S and L and slightly smaller for M. The ten-percent rule also reduced returns across all three sizes. It reduced the deepest decline relative to continuous participation in this test, but did not cap it at ten percent.

Time changed too. For size S, the five-percent rule extended the longest period between equity highs from 7.4 to 49.7 months in the backtest. This variant held cash for 29 percent of the time. A pause can therefore mean a long departure from the system originally tested.

03

Why can a pause change so much?

Exiting does not remove the decline that triggered the exit. While the follower holds cash, they do not participate in a possible recovery of the model portfolio. Under the tested rule, they return only after that portfolio exceeds its previous high. Until then, the follower's account follows a different path.

This explains why the pause was costly in Sven's retrospective calculation. It does not establish a universal rule that every exit is harmful. An exit for another reason, or a different re-entry rule, would be a different test. Sven compared this precise combination: pause at a five- or ten-percent decline and return at the model portfolio's next high.

04

The harder part: time below the last high

A drawdown need not be deep to become difficult to live with. In Sven's backtest, each of the three original EGS curves spent 73 to 74 percent of the time below its previous high. A long period without a new high can create doubt even when the strategy still follows its rules. Loss aversionLoss aversion describes the fact that losses weigh more heavily psychologically than gains of the same size. can strengthen the impulse to react immediately to a visible decline. Skipping trades or changing size from day to day means following a different variant from the one previously tested.

In Trading Podcast #157, “Drawdown in Trading: Why Taking a Break Can Hurt”, Oliver and Sven discuss the rule using Equity Growth System curves. From 18:07, they compare the five- and ten-percent pauses with continuous participation. The conversation is in German; YouTube's English subtitles may help. They also discuss how drawdowns feel and why past lows do not set a ceiling on future losses.

05

Decide before the first trade

Sven's comparison suggests a practical question before following a system: what decline and how long without a new high could your chosen position size mean for your account? The deepest historical drawdown is an observation, not a limit. Future losses can be larger.

The trader chooses the capital committed and the risk taken. A smaller position changes both potential monetary losses and potential gains; it does not replace checking whether the rules still apply or deciding what to do if a meaningful assumption breaks. A divergence between a personal account and the model portfolio may also deserve investigation. This backtest cannot establish a blanket obligation to keep trading through every decline.

For context on the Equity Growth System, read “Stock Trading Systems” for rules and backtest basics. The Equity Growth System page describes the sizes, requirements and current backtest presentation. Its figures have a more recent data cut-off; do not combine them with Sven's September 2026 table as one time series.

06

Frequently asked questions

Does exiting at five percent limit my loss to five percent?

No. In Sven's tested rule, a decline in the model portfolio triggers the pause. Your account can differ; five percent is not a guaranteed loss limit. For S and L, the deepest historical backtest drawdown with this pause was greater than with continuous participation.

Must I always keep trading through a drawdown?

No. The calculation evaluates one specific pause and re-entry rule in historical data. It does not replace checking whether the strategy still applies, whether orders are executed correctly and whether your chosen risk remains bearable.

Are the table values actual trading results?

No. They are hypothetical backtest results for 3 January 2000 to 8 September 2026, analysed by Sven Otremba on 13 September 2026. Actual execution may differ. Historical results do not reliably predict the future, and stock trading can lead to loss of invested capital.


Sources and context: Sven Otremba, “Exiting During a Drawdown” (analysis dated 13 September 2026) and notes for “Titan Pitfalls”, episode 2 (13 September 2026); TradeNeon Titan and Lab of Trades product masters. On hypothetical backtests, see the SEC Investor Bulletin on Performance Claims.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances
What is Futures Insights? Three fundamentals for your futures analysis

What is Futures Insights? Three fundamentals for your futures analysis

Brown FI capybara at a desk with an FI gold view on the monitor.
Futures InsightsSoftware explained

What is
Futures Insights?

Futures Insights (FI) is TradeNeon's web-based analysis software for futures traders. It brings together COT data, seasonality and term structure in one view. You can identify markets worth a closer look and compare the fundamental picture with your own setup.

FI in focus: an illustration based on the gold seasonality view. The image tour contains original English software captures.Image: TradeNeon

01

What do you use Futures Insights for?

You open the COT data, check a seasonal curve and compare prices across futuresA future is a standardized forward contract that obligates the trading partners to a transaction in the future. contract months. Each view answers a different question. The real work starts when you bring them together: Does the seasonal pattern fit current positioning? Does the term structure support your assessment? Or do the data disagree?

This is where Futures Insights fits in. The software brings these three perspectives together. Its dashboard covers 26 futures markets across eight sectors. From the overview, you can open an individual market's detail view and examine how its assessment is formed.

FI is mainly for traders who swing trade or position trade futures or optionsThe buyer of an option pays a premium for the right to buy or sell a stock or a future at a fixed price and within a fixed period of time. on futures, thinking in days or weeks. It does not provide a trigger for entries measured in seconds. Its role is in preparation: Which markets deserve your attention today?

02

Three fundamentals, five indicators

FI calculates three fundamentals and displays them through five indicators. The data sources are COT data, seasonality and term structure. The indicators help you assess different characteristics of those data.

Explore FI · Gold (GC)

Switch between real software views. Use “Enlarge” to read labels and details.

Original capture · 23 October 2026
The upper view combines price and seasonal phases. Below it is the weighted Seasonals Score; line colour shows consensus.

Interactive tour of saved software views. Find current data in Futures Insights.

Gold (GC) · captured 23 October 2026

At original size, you can scroll the image horizontally and vertically.

COT data: How are market participants positioned?

The Commitments of Traders reports from the US regulator CFTC show the open positions of different trader groups. They provide a view of a market's composition. What you see is aggregated positioning, rather than individual trading plans or intentions.

FI calculates OBOS and Dry Powder from COT data. OBOS stands for Overbought/Oversold and puts into context how one-sided each trader group's positioning is. Dry Powder incorporates open interest and the number of trading institutions holding positions. Open interest is the number of outstanding contracts.

An extreme reading does not tell you when a market will turn. COT data help you assess direction from a fundamental perspective. They are not a timing tool for trade entries.

COT data are not a live feed: The CFTC publishes traders' positions from the previous Tuesday every Friday, although holidays can change the schedule. FI's daily update does not change this rhythm. The CFTC explains the reports and their publication schedule.

Seasonality: What does price history show?

Seasonality examines recurring patterns over the course of a year. FI evaluates long-term price history and displays a weighted score. Consensus bands also show how closely the years examined agree on a seasonal phase.

This helps you distinguish an average shaped by several similar price paths from one influenced by a few unusual years. Current market conditions remain a separate question. Historical agreement does not promise the same outcome next year or establish a future win rate.

Term structure: How do contract months differ?

The term structure compares prices across delivery months in a futures market. When nearby contracts trade above later ones, this downward-sloping curve is described as backwardation. An upward-sloping curve, with higher prices for later contracts, is described as contango.

FI adds Z-Score and Z-Momentum to this analysis. Z-Score puts the value being examined into the context of its own history. Z-Momentum shows how that reading changes. You can assess the extent of a term-structure condition and its change separately.

The curve needs to be understood in the context of its market. For physically delivered commodities, factors can include storage, financing and the benefit of having the commodity available immediately. Contango therefore does not automatically mean oversupply; backwardation alone does not prove that prices are about to rise. CME explains the underlying factors.

03

What does the combined view add?

A COT indicator examines positioning. A seasonal curve shows historical patterns. The term structure compares contract months. In FI, you can examine these sources side by side and investigate their differences.

Consider a hypothetical example in gold: Seasonality points in a particular direction, positioning fits that assessment and the term structure appears consistent with it. This gives you a market hypothesis to examine further on the chart. It does not yet give you an entry.

If positioning contradicts the seasonal pattern, that difference deserves a closer look. You may put your assessment on hold, examine more information or choose another market under your rules. The software helps you organise these questions. Agreement between several readings does not establish a statistical edge or the profitability of a trade.

04

How does FI fit into your trading routine?

Start with the market overview and choose a market to examine. Open its detail view and ask whether positioning, seasonality and term structure form a coherent picture. Build a reasoned assessment, including the points that still argue against it.

Then apply your own trading rules: Is there a suitable setup? Where would you enter? What would invalidate the idea? What position size fits your risk? These decisions remain yours. FI provides the fundamental context; you define entry and risk limits through your trading rules.

If you want to understand positioning data in more depth first, read COT data in trading. Position sizing and risk management also belong in your preparation for execution.

  • Gold (GC) free
  • All indicators
  • No credit card
05

Frequently asked questions about Futures Insights

What does FI mean in trading?

Here, FI stands for Futures Insights, TradeNeon's web-based analysis software. It combines COT data, seasonality and term structure so you can consider the fundamental market environment in your futures analysis.

Which five indicators does Futures Insights include?

Dry Powder and OBOS are based on COT data. The other indicators are seasonality, plus Z-Score and Z-Momentum from the term structure. Consensus bands add context to the seasonal display; open interest is an input to the COT analysis.

Who is Futures Insights for?

FI is for swing traders and position traders who trade futures or options on futures. Its analysis supports the market overview and preparation. It is not a short-term timing tool for scalpingScalping is a very short-term trading approach in which positions are often held for only seconds or minutes..

Do I need to install anything?

No. Futures Insights is web-based and runs in your browser.

What is free in the Free Plan?

Gold (GC), with all indicators. Registration requires no payment details or credit card. You can open the Free Plan here.

Can Futures Insights make a trading decision for me?

The software supports your analysis. You remain responsible for the setup, entry, position size and risk. Subsequent price action can invalidate even an assessment in which the fundamentals agree.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances
Can you really make a living from trading?

Can you really make a living from trading?

A person looks across a lake into a night sky filled with glowing candlesticks and a chart line.
TradingOrientation

Can you really
make a living from trading?

You look up at the sky and imagine what your life could be like. Perhaps with more time for the things that matter to you, or a second source of income. Perhaps even with the opportunity to make a living from trading one day. But is what you want really possible?

Illustration.Image: TradeNeon

What it means to make a living from trading

Yes, it is possible to earn money from trading and make a living from it. Perhaps you want to build an additional income first. Perhaps your long-term goal is to gradually reduce your working hours and eventually live entirely from trading. These are possibilities you can explore for yourself.

For your own path, it makes a difference whether you want to make your first profits, build capital or pay your regular expenses. A profitable trade shows that a single decision has earned money. To cover your living expenses, you need results that match those expenses after costs and, where applicable, taxes, while also allowing for weaker trading periods.

Your skills, the capital available to you and the time you can invest all matter. A small account needs to earn a much higher percentage returnThe gain from a financial product over a given period, expressed as a percentage. than a large one to produce the same amount of money. Assuming a high return does not reliably compensate for a lack of capital in everyday life.

This reality check gives your ambition a direction. You can identify what you already bring to the process and what you still want to develop. Perhaps your path begins with learning alongside your job and growing your own account. That turns a big goal into steps you can actually work on.

Why learning can become a maze

Getting started seems accessible today. You can find videos, podcasts, books and posts about almost every trading approach. One video explains day tradingOpening and closing positions within a single trading day.; the next promises a particularly effective indicator. Soon afterwards, you see someone showing profits made with AI. Everything seems to open up another possibility.

Your learning can then take a path that resembles a maze: you move from one strategy to the next before understanding its requirements. You become familiar with more technical terms, but cannot yet explain why you would enter a particular trade. Having watched a lot does not yet give you a direction for your own decisions.

A screenshot of a winning trade leaves important questions unanswered: How much capital was used? What losses came before it? What costs apply? Can you follow the rules behind the trade? Without this information, you have only a limited basis for assessing how the result relates to your own path.

YouTube can provide good explanations and practical insights. What matters is how you select and work through the content. Are you collecting more ideas, or developing an understanding you can test for yourself? This is where the path out of the maze begins.

How to separate useful information from the noise

You can recognise reliable information by being able to examine its basis and its limitations. Before adopting an approach, these questions can help:

  • Are sources, data and assumptions provided so that you can check them yourself?
  • Can you distinguish a substantiated statement from a personal opinion?
  • Are losses, costs and risks explained alongside possible profits?
  • Are the rules for entries, exits and position sizing clear?
  • Can you see whether someone earns money from a recommendation, for example through advertising or referral payments?

The European regulator ESMA identifies transparency about interests, separating facts from opinions and presenting risks fairly as important requirements for financial communication. As a reader, these points also give you practical criteria for choosing your sources. [1]

To begin with, you can focus on a few sources you can evaluate and one trading discipline. When you do not understand an explanation, write down the question and look for a specific answer. Your learning goal can then determine which information you need next.

Selection and learning develop together. You do not need to be an experienced trader to ask questions or recognise an unsupported claim. As your knowledge grows, you can assess more precisely which statements fit the markets, instruments and rules you want to learn about.

How information becomes knowledge and skill

You build knowledge when you understand connections and can explain them in your own words. In trading, that includes how your market works, the instruments you trade, order types, position sizing and risks. You should be able to explain why a setup fits your trading plan and under which conditions you would choose not to trade it.

Skill develops through practice and evaluation. A structured learning path might look like this:

  • You learn the fundamentals and formulate the rules of your approach so that you can explain them yourself.
  • You practise applying them in a demo account first and document your decisions, including mistakes.
  • You evaluate whether you followed the rules, what results you achieved and which assumptions you still need to examine.

A profit can result from a poorly justified decision. A loss can occur even when you follow your trading rules. It is therefore useful to assess the quality of your decision separately from the financial outcome. Demo trading helps you practise; execution, costs and managing real money can introduce additional demands later.

AI as a tool and a sparring partner

AI can support your learning. You can ask it to explain terms, work through questions to check your understanding or look for counterarguments to an assumption. You can also ask it to examine a trading rule you have written for ambiguities. Used this way, the tool helps you think more carefully about your own approach.

Trading with AI is not the holy grail, however. A fluent answer can be wrong, incomplete or out of date. The UK's Financial Conduct Authority describes AI as a tool for understanding and research and recommends checking information against its original sources. [2]

You can therefore use AI while you are learning. What matters is that you verify its answers and recognise unresolved questions. If you cannot yet assess the rules and risks of a suggested strategy, you need further foundations before using it to make a trading decision. An AI answer is not evidence that an approach is profitable.

Continue with a structured learning path

If you would like guidance along this path, the pages for the day trading programme and swing trading programme explain their content and structure. Both programmes and these linked pages are currently available in German.

Small groups leave room for your questions and feedback on your own trades.

For us, theory, practice and feedback belong together. That is what creates a sound learning path.

How realistic expectations change your progress

Your goal can be ambitious. To support your progress, it helps to separate your expectations for the learning phase from those for a future income. At the beginning, you can work on understanding the market, applying your rules consistently and evaluating your decisions in a way you can follow.

Imagine expecting to earn a fixed amount for your regular expenses in your very first month. If the profit does not materialise, every next trade could feel like something that has to work. After a loss, it may seem tempting to trade more or take more risk to recover it quickly. That expectation can create additional pressure.

You can assess your learning progress through different questions:

  • Can I explain my approach and its risks clearly?
  • Do I follow my rules even when there is no suitable setup or a trade loses?
  • Do I document my decisions in a way that helps me recognise mistakes and progress?

An evaluation can help you identify whether a losing period is part of the fluctuations of your approach or whether rules, execution or assumptions need reviewing. Good periods deserve the same scrutiny. A short winning streak alone is not a sound basis for your living expenses.

Give your learning phase a financial framework that fits your everyday life. Your job and savings can allow you to build knowledge and experience while your regular expenses remain covered. You can then measure progress through more than the amount earned in a single trading month.

From a second income to a possible livelihood

You can gradually develop the role trading plays in your life. A second source of income alongside your job is a worthwhile goal in its own right. You can start by learning, building your own capital from your income and examining how a trading routine fits into your daily life.

In swing tradingTrading price movements over a medium- to longer-term holding period., positions are held for days to weeks. Preparation and reviewing your rules can therefore be organised differently from trading within a single day. Day trading requires time for the trading session itself, as well as preparation and review. The right path also depends on when you can make that time available.

For an approach alongside your job, you can explore the swing trading programme. If you want to allocate more time to daily trading, the day trading programme offers the other training path. Consider the content and structure of each in relation to your daily life. Both programmes are currently delivered in German.

Keep the savings you need for living expenses separate from the capital you risk in trading. Losses can also substantially reduce your trading capital. In its guidance for US securities day trading, FINRA explicitly cautions against using funds needed for living expenses or important long-term goals as trading capital. [3]

Test your assumptions with the return calculator

How do starting capital, monthly savings and withdrawals interact? What changes when you adjust your assumed return or time horizon? In the return calculator, you can explore your own scenario and compare the swing trading and day trading tabs. The calculator is currently available in German.

The calculator shows results under the assumptions you enter. A desired income that is mathematically possible is not yet an income you have reliably earned. It is therefore particularly important to examine how your plan looks with weaker results and whether your savings and other income sources match your financial needs.

Prop trading or funded trader models can also offer a way to trade. Check whether trading takes place in a real or simulated account, which fees and loss limits apply and when payouts are possible. The advertised account size is not your freely available wealth. These models require a separate review of their contractual terms. [4]

If your actual results after costs match your expenses over a longer period and your financial protection is sound, you can consider changing your working hours. Weaker trading periods, taxes where applicable and the dependence of your income on markets remain part of that decision. Multiple sources of income can give you additional options.

You are allowed to imagine making a living from trading one day. The reality check shows you what you can work on along the way: develop a learning process you can follow, review your decisions and build capital. Your next step today can be to clarify your starting point and explore the training path that fits you.

Sources and context
  1. ESMA: Finfluencers – tips for responsible promotion (German factsheet)
  2. FCA: Using AI for investment research (updated 30 July 2026)
  3. FINRA Rule 2270: Day-Trading Risk Disclosure Statement (US securities day trading)
  4. FSMA: Warning about consumer prop trading models examined (7 March 2024)
Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances

This blog is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations to buy or sell. Trading and investing in financial markets involve significant risks, including the loss of all invested capital. You make and remain responsible for your own decisions.

Learning day trading: which path is right?

Learning day trading: which path is right?

How to read the stock market

How to read the stock market


Oliver Sparing in an Interview: Order Flow and Swing Trading

Oliver Sparing in an Interview: Order Flow and Swing Trading

Two upholstered armchairs face each other, with a studio microphone on a boom arm between them.
VideoInterview

Oliver Sparing in an Interview:
Order Flow and
Swing Trading

Knowledge and hard work beat talent, and Oliver Sparing is proof of that. In day trading, his day begins with market analysis, only then does the order book confirm the plan, and in swing trading his portfolio is spread across several strategies. The interview at Insider Trading is about his path from commodities to order flow and the routine that grew out of it.

A long conversation about one path into trading, without shortcuts.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

The trading day in order flow day trading begins with the market analysis: dark pool data, CME SPAN data, options data and dealer hedging produce zones in which institutional interest is likely to sit. At the level, the order book confirms the plan, and a setup should be statistically evaluable. In swing trading, the portfolio is spread across several strategies, CoT data and seasonality form a foundation, the entry comes from the chart, and risk stays conservative.

01

The video

The video is in German. For English audio, open the settings (gear icon) in the player and choose Audio track → English.

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 27

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: Insider TradingMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

Oliver's path to trading

Oliver comes from the commodities field. Around 2010 and 2011, he engages with the exchange; professionally, he trades physical investment metals such as coins and bars at the time, not on an exchange.

He loses his first CFD account on the first evening, and that becomes the occasion to learn the exchange from the ground up. Swing trading and options trading follow, the first discipline in which things worked out for him. Later, day trading and order book and order flow trading are added, today his hobbyhorses. Alongside, he continues to trade options, including zero-DTE options, as well as futures, commodities and stocks.

He learned the craft of day trading on a trading floor in London. Oliver was no natural talent: he had to work hard for much of it, and it took a long time until he became profitable. Because he is an emotional person, he adapts positions and risk to his character.

Many younger people today start with CFDs and crypto. Whoever has no personal contact with the exchange first meets the loudest providers, like the advertising boards at the edge of the pitch in a football stadium. Back then, the path led to exchange-regulated instruments such as stocks, futures and options, because there you do not, when in doubt, trade against your own broker. Today, the choice of brokers is larger, and there are many good CFD and crypto brokers.

03

Where a trade is worth considering

The day in order flow day trading begins with an extensive market analysis. It is important to understand which setups you trade, and at least as important where you trade them. For that, Oliver evaluates several data sources every morning: data from dark pools, the CME's SPANThe risk model that futures exchanges such as the CME use to calculate margin requirements. A risk interval around the closing price can be derived from it. data, options data and dealer hedging data, plus the liquidity in the order book as well as volume profiles and market profiles.

The combination produces zones in which institutional interest is likely to sit. This gives the plan for the day: where trades come into question, where not (at least as important) and in which direction. “Market analysis is the be-all and end-all. You never want to trade somewhere in the middle of nowhere,” says Oliver Sparing. He still does the analysis by hand. TradeNeon's software is a mirror of it: it brings the levels into the charts of various platforms.

Dealer hedging

At the center is dealer hedgingMarket makers hedge their options positions in the underlying and adjust this hedge continuously.. On the other side of an options trade usually sits a market makerMarket participants who continuously quote buy and sell prices and want to live off the spread rather than the direction of price.. They do not want to buy cheap and sell higher but to profit from the spread and get rid of the trade again immediately. If that does not work, they have directional risk and neutralize it in the underlying, for example in the S&P 500 future. Because the option does not move in the same rhythm as the underlying, they have to adjust this hedge continuously. Models can be used to estimate where market makers are positioned and under what circumstances they would have to buy or sell.

CoT data are relevant in the medium to longer term and bring no edge in intraday trading. Dealer hedging, by contrast, offers possible price zones for the trading day. It remains a working hypothesis: market makers have great influence, but the other market participants know their constraints as well. Whether a zone holds only becomes clear at the level. Placing a limit order blindly at a level and hoping for the best does not work for that reason. A stop has to fit the day's volatility, and an unexpected piece of news can run it over. That is why you need a setup at the level.

Icon of the dealer hedging course
Dealer hedging course
Understand dealer hedging from the ground up
Learn about options, the Greeks and how possible hedging areas are calculated. The course uses examples from options, stocks and futures. It is currently taught in German.
Explore the course in German

What happens in the order book

When the market comes to a previously defined level, Oliver looks into the order book. Heatmap and classic order book both have their use; he works a lot with the heatmapThe heatmap shows the order book over time: where limit orders sat and how large they were. and combines the two views. What he watches is how liquidity shifts, where orders are filled, where new ones come in, where rebalancing takes place and how the delta changes. The order book is meant to confirm the plan made beforehand.

There is no clear trigger in day trading that says “buy.” What you see in the order book has to be interpreted. The point is not to get lost in market understanding and to end up with a repeatable setup whose statistical edge you have evaluated. More aggressive entries and waiting for more confirmation both have their price: whoever waits for more confirmation gives up some of the reward-to-risk ratio. The range can become extreme, all the way to unprofitability. That is why statistics matter: whether a setup has an edge only becomes clear through evaluation.

With AI, it is now conceivable to implement such strategies algorithmically, with caution. One advantage in discretionary day trading, however, can lie precisely in the room for human interpretation, which makes you independent of the classic algorithms in the market.

The five factors in order flow

  • Passive market participants How do limit orders shift in the order book, where are they filled, where does spoofingLarge orders that are placed in the order book and removed again before execution in order to influence the market. take place?
  • Active market participants Who moves the market with market orders, and is there a shift in delta?
  • Market and auction speed This is easier to observe in the classic order book. Does the market start to “wriggle”?
  • Order flow events AbsorptionLarge amounts of aggressive orders are taken up by limit orders without price moving on., stop run, exhaustion, sweeps.
  • Price action In the microstructure, it is at least as relevant as on a daily or monthly chart.

What is decisive is that these processes take place at price zones that are relevant for institutions. Only a small part of what constantly happens in the market is usable. Beginners especially see an opportunity around every corner after the first concepts such as absorption or iceberg orders.

04

At the level, the reaction is what counts

Oliver trades the US session, above all the first one to two hours after the open in New York and the last two trading hours. He trades almost exclusively the ES future, the S&P 500 future. In the past, it was also the gold and crude oil futures. For the ES, he has the most data that give him an additional edge.

First, he looks at his picture of the market: hourly and four-hour chart, which higher-level market phase the market is in, how it reacted to his levels. Then he works out a plan and sets an alert at the next relevant price level. A common beginner mistake is to sit in front of it and drive yourself crazy because you see an opportunity around every corner. He waits patiently until the market comes to the zone and then watches the order book.

For that, he uses a classic candlestick chart on 5 minutes, “a good old 5-minute chart.” A 1-minute or 15-minute chart is just as fine. On top come a market profile and a volume profile to follow auction methods and market structure. In practice, he works with a combination of Bookmap and TradingView. For order book data, you need live market data from the exchange and software such as Bookmap or Quantower, combined with a data feed.

Oliver steers clear of news releases. He is no news trader but knows there are strong ones. Shortly before important US economic data, market makers pull liquidity out of the order book: in the heatmap, a wall of orders suddenly disappears. A few minutes after the release, the liquidity gradually comes back, and then he trades again. Classic order book trading largely leaves the realm of economics anyway; market mechanics play the role here. The longer term a trade is meant to be, the more fundamental factors count.

05

In swing trading, the portfolio comes first

Order flow day trading takes a longer familiarization period, and you have to confirm for yourself that your own approach has an edge, ideally through statistics. Whoever has not proven for themselves that it works has a hard time psychologically, because doubts keep coming back. In swing trading, things are often calmer, and approaches are easier to replicate and teach. Anyone who decides on a day trading programme also brings a certain stress factor into their life and should have a great interest in the markets. “I am absolutely no fan of this credo, trade like a machine. We are not machines, we are human beings. We have emotions, and we have to learn to deal with them,” says Oliver Sparing. When he notices that he is reacting more emotionally, he does not day trade in that phase.

Several strategies instead of one

Oliver builds his trading portfolio like a long-term stock portfolio: with diversification, meaning with several strategies that correlate as little as possible. Whoever relies on only one can go through a bad phase over a longer period. He has seen this himself with classic income strategies using options on the ES future and the SPX. For a start, however, it is important to learn one strategy properly first and to broaden out only afterwards. In swing trading, he works with four building blocks.

  • Commodity trading with CoT data The theoretical foundation is CoT data, seasonal patterns and term structure, combined with a setup that is logical in terms of market technicals.
  • Strategy on the 4-hour chart It combines market structure and auction logic with Fibonacci retracements.
  • Three stock strategies His own indicators pre-filter stocks by various criteria. He then enters on momentum or on pullbacks.
  • Options strategies Options strategies are the fourth building block.

Swing trading is his “bread and butter.” How day and swing trading are distributed among clients fluctuates: sometimes there is more interest in one, sometimes in the other. Some add day trading after a while; others notice in day trading that it stresses them too much and switch to swing trading.

CoT data and own indicators

In commodities, CoT data are a base filter, comparable to the market analysis in day trading. Oliver has developed his own indicators that go beyond the classic Larry Williams index. The index looks at the net position, and a purely absolute view of positioning can say little. The data are therefore put in relation to total open interestThe number of all open contracts in a futures market., producers and processors are looked at separately, and the positioning is also put in relation to price. On top of that, it counts how many institutions hold a position: a high open interest held by only a few is less meaningful than one spread across many. The absolute view runs as a dry powderAn indicator of how much room a positioning still has before it is historically stretched. indicator; the relative one through an OBOS framework.

Alone, this usually gives no edge. It gives a good fundamental starting position in which a suitable setup then makes sense. Because CoT trading is usually trading against a strong trend, and a trend is more likely to continue than to reverse, it takes patience and a sensible setup. The wait is for a prominent volume peak in the volume profile and for the market to break out of it against the trend direction for the first time. The value of CoT data lies less in finding good entries than in finding trades with a lot of potential in the desired direction when the market moves. How CoT data work in principle is explained in detail in the video article on the ATAS webinar.

On the question of which trader group counts: the commercials have the most expertise about their market, but their intention has become less clear because they speculate more today than they used to. With managed moneySpeculative large investors in the disaggregated CoT report, such as hedge funds., the intention is clearer. In the evaluations the TradeNeon team has done over the years, the positioning of this speculative group showed the highest correlation with price. The thought behind dry powder: if everyone who was historically long is already long, who is left to buy?

Seasonality

On seasonality in commodities, the indicators determine the patterns on the basis of adjusted contracts (back-adjustmentPrices of old contracts are adjusted for the roll gaps so that a continuous chart results.), because roll gaps between contracts would otherwise distort a pattern. At the start of the year, the patterns of all relevant markets are reviewed, determined algorithmically, ten years back. Interesting are patterns lasting on average about ten trading days, up to a month. With longer ones, you have to expect corrections. Over the ten-year period, the market should have moved in the direction of the seasonality in at least nine of the last ten years, and the evaluation is market-specific: a volatile market cannot be equated with a calm one.

A seasonality is one fundamental factor among several and, just like CoT data, not a pure entry trigger. What is sought are entries based on auction logic, with a chart-technical entry. Today Oliver also trades against a seasonality now and then when everything else speaks for a dream setup, which he would not have done a few years ago. For Oliver, seasonalities in commodities play a smaller role today than they did a few years ago.

06

Risk belongs in the plan

On risk, position size always stays very conservative, and Oliver has never leveraged massively, in day trading as in swing trading. His margin is rarely used up far. Because the risk per trade is small, he can have several positions open in parallel in the stock strategies.

“I think trading is a craft. Anyone who is interested and brings a little passion can learn it, up to the point where you earn money with it and are profitable,” says Oliver Sparing. Whether someone wants to live from it alone is a question of type. Oliver would not advise anyone to rely on trading alone too early in their career. A second source of income is entirely legitimate.

As a teacher, he enjoys the work because he can help others move forward. His coaches have all gone through his programme.

At the end, Oliver gives viewers this to take along: “Be patient. The path is worth it, but it can be quite long and rocky, and that is entirely normal. Make sure you stay at it with joy and stay in the demo account as long as possible to gather experience.” Trading has a lot to do with experience and with your own character.

07

What you can take away from the interview

  • The place comes before the setup. First, you determine in the market analysis where institutional interest is likely to sit. Without this plan, a trade has no point of reference.
  • The order book confirms the plan. At the level, it is not the mark alone that decides but what happens in the order book.
  • Statistics show whether a setup works. Whoever has not confirmed for themselves that their approach has an edge will have a hard time psychologically.
  • Data such as CoT and seasonality are a foundation. They give a starting position. The entry comes from the setup in the chart.

“What many do not want to admit at the beginning of their trading career is that, as traders, we are first and foremost mathematicians and statisticians.”

Oliver Sparing in the interview at Insider Trading (translated from German)
08

About the interview

The interview appeared on March 29, 2026 on the YouTube channel Insider Trading. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on YouTube's subtitle translation. Everything stated here is Oliver's personal experience and assessment from the conversation. The channel points out that the video is not investment advice and that trading involves considerable risks. Oliver is also a guest with other partners; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Day trading programme
How do you build your own trading routine?
A routine like Oliver's, from market analysis to the order book, is something you build step by step. In our day trading programme, you learn how. The programme is currently offered in German.
Day trading programme (German)
Frequently asked questions
What does a trading day in order flow day trading look like?

It starts with the market analysis: dark pools, SPAN data, options data and dealer hedging produce zones in which institutional interest is likely to sit. When the market comes to such a level, the order book is watched and confirmation of the plan is sought there.

Are CoT data alone enough for a trade?

Usually not. CoT data give a good fundamental starting position but no entry. For that, you need a setup that the market forms at the level, for example the breakout from a volume peak against the trend direction.

What software and data do you need for order flow day trading?

For order book data, you need live market data from the exchange and software such as Bookmap or Quantower in combination with a data feed. In practice, Oliver works with a combination of Bookmap and TradingView.

Is there trading around news releases?

Oliver steers clear of news around important US economic data. Shortly beforehand, market makers pull liquidity out of the order book; a few minutes after the release it comes back, and then he trades again.

Marnie Aramruck
Marnie Aramruck
Founder & Head of Brand & Psychology · TradeNeon
Marnie Aramruck came to trading by an unusual route: ten years self-employed in event management, marketing and design, before turning to the psychology behind decisions. As a master emotion coach and resilience trainer, she now works on a single question: what traders need in order to stay calm and clear even under pressure. Her subject is not the chart, but the person in front of it.