Futures or Options in Day Trading: What Fits Your Daily Life?

Futures or Options in Day Trading: What Fits Your Daily Life?

A taut wooden bow with a horizontally placed arrow sits beside an open coral-colored umbrella.
VideoWH SelfInvest webinar

Futures or Options in Day Trading:
What Fits Your Daily Life?

Anyone who thinks of day trading usually thinks of futures: buy, set a stop, speculate on the direction of price. Alongside it, selling options is a second possibility, one that behaves differently in reward-to-risk ratio, hit rate and time commitment. This article compares both instruments, follows a recorded trade and names the downside clearly.

The same entry, two instruments: one needs a precise target, the other forgives more.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

In a future, you give the trade a stop and aim for a good reward-to-risk ratio; with a sold option, you collect a premium, speculate that price will not reach a certain level or will not run far against you, and benefit from time decay. That can lead to a higher hit rate and forgives more mistakes in the entry; whether it works out depends on strike, time to expiration and risk management, and the premium is compensation for an obligation and a risk, not proof of a profitable system. The profit is capped at the premium, the option writer's risk of loss tends to be larger than that profit and, on a sold call without protection, theoretically unlimited, and the instrument demands understanding and protection.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 27

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: WH SelfInvest DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

Two ideas of trading

How futures and options differ for the day trader and what suits whom comes down to everyday life. Most people picture trading like this: buy cheap and sell higher, or the other way round, sell short high and buy back lower. That is the conventional idea of speculating directionally on the price of a market. Alongside it, the option is an instrument that opens up possibilities that are particularly interesting for retail traders and can make everyday life more manageable.

A warning comes with it. “The option is a complex trading instrument, and I am a big fan of only trading what you have truly understood, not just roughly understood, but really knowing what you are doing,” says Oliver Sparing. You do not have to go deep into the subject, but you should know what a put is, what a call is, which rights the buyer and which obligations the seller has, and how the relation to the current price (at the money, in the money, out of the money) plays out. All of this can be learned, but it is more complex than buying a stock.

03

The option as an insurance business

The basic idea can be compared to health insurance. Every month, you pay the insurer a premium that you do not get back, and in return you acquire a right that you can use in an emergency but do not have to. The insurer has to calculate its premiums so that it works at a profit with high probability. If they were too low, it would soon be bankrupt.

Options have a similar setup. The buyer acquires a right, and the option writerThe seller of an option. They take on the obligation if the buyer exercises their right., meaning the seller, takes on an obligation in return. What that looks like depends on the type of option. With a call optionThe right to buy the underlying at an agreed price within a set term. With index options such as those on the SPX, there is a cash settlement claim instead. on a stock or a future, the buyer has the right to buy the underlying at an agreed price; with a put optionThe right to sell the underlying at an agreed price within a set term. With index options such as those on the SPX, there is a cash settlement claim instead., the right to sell it at an agreed price; the option writer then has to deliver or take delivery. With index options such as those on the SPX, nothing is delivered; they settle in cash instead: the buyer receives the amount by which the index is above (call) or below (put) the agreed price at expiration. The buyer pays the premiumThe price of the option. The buyer pays it when buying and can sell the option again before expiration, receiving its current price. The option writer is credited with it on the sale and keeps all of it if the option expires worthless or is not bought back at a higher price. when buying. Before expiration, the buyer can sell the option again and then receives its current price. If the price rises very far on a call, the buyer can make a large profit, and in the worst case the option writer faces an incalculable risk. Their maximum profit, by contrast, is capped at the premium.

From this, a statistical edgeOliver's term for the assumption that option premiums compensate the seller for their risk on average. It is not a built-in profit: the result depends on strike, time to expiration and risk management. for the seller can be derived: as with the insurer, the premium has to be set so that the seller is compensated for the obligation and the risk, otherwise nobody would sell options. That is an argument, not proof: the premium is payment for an obligation and a risk, not proof of a profitable system. Whether a seller earns money over time depends, among other things, on strike, time to expiration, position size and risk management. How the role of the option writer and protection work in detail is explained at more length in the ATAS webinar that we describe in this article: Zero-DTE Options or Futures in Day Trading. Here, the focus is on the comparison with the future and on the trader's everyday life.

04

Trading discretionarily or statistically

In directional trading as well as in options trading, you can distinguish two ways of trading. Discretionary tradingTrading based on your own assessment of the market, for example from the order book. means you look at what happens in the order book, interpret the market, form an opinion and enter a trade on that basis. Statistical tradingTrading by fixed, clear rules: when certain conditions occur, you trade in a predefined way. is based on fixed, clear rules: if A, B and C happen, I do D.

Ten to twenty years ago, statistical trading was still the standard, in the retail space too. Strategies such as the crossing of two moving averages worked back then, even intraday. Such plain rules alone hardly get you anywhere today: anyone who wants to trade statistically has to think much more intricately. There are still strategies that work purely rule-based, but they are no longer as quick to find as they used to be.

In options trading, the classic strategies are statistical: they rely on the premium compensating the seller for their risk on average. The rules might say, for example, to sell a put option at a fixed strike every day at the opening of the US market. There are losers along the way; whether the edge shows over the long run depends on strike, time to expiration, position size and risk management. Anyone who has already looked into the subject comes across this kind of options trading. Less well known is that you can also use options discretionarily: you take your entries from the order book, for example from the heatmapThe heatmap shows the order book over time: where limit orders sat and how large they were., and implement them with an option instead of the future. That brings the occasional small disadvantage but a number of advantages.

05

Everyday day trading: time, hit rate and reward-to-risk ratio

Many traders have a job and a family and cannot sit at the market six hours every day. Day trading is still supposed to add value to your life, first and foremost financially, but also as an activity that is fun. Classic discretionary order book trading is a path with a long learning phase: it is rarely learned in a few months and goes hand in hand with a lot of experience. On top of that, everyone has to find the trading style that suits them. Many roads lead to Rome; there is no single right strategy.

Then comes the question many people wrestle with: reward-to-risk ratioThe ratio of the possible profit to the possible loss of a trade. or hit rate? On the internet, you often read that the reward-to-risk ratio is everything. That is not entirely wrong, because it is an important factor. But it is only one of four factors of the risk quadrantThe four factors reward-to-risk ratio, hit rate, risk per trade and trading frequency, which influence each other.: reward-to-risk ratio, hit rate, risk per trade and trading frequency. They influence each other, above all hit rate and reward-to-risk ratio. Anyone who chooses a strategy with a higher hit rate usually has to accept a lower reward-to-risk ratio in the end, and the other way round.

How far this can go shows an experience from London: Oliver Sparing met traders on a prop trading floor there who work with a very low hit rate and a very high reward-to-risk ratio. “That is never something I could or would teach my clients. They would all go crazy, and that includes me,” he says. Anyone who makes only one trade a day and rarely wins can trade through an entire month without a single winning trade. At some point, frustration sets in, motivation suffers, and you quit. The hit rate is therefore by no means unimportant. A strategy that settles at a healthy middle ground between reward-to-risk ratio and hit rate makes sense.

Even with such a strategy, it can happen that you sit at the computer five days a week, wait in your trading window for the one good setup and still end every day with a red number. That is not unusual, and an experienced trader can handle it. What matters is what is left at the end of the month and, even more so, at the end of the year. There is a different approach that is meant to combine both worlds and can be more pleasant in everyday life, for your wallet as well as for your psyche: entering trades not directionally in the future but by selling options. The hit rate is often clearly higher this way.

06

Chart example: stop in the future or sold put option

On the 5-minute chart of the ES, the E-mini future on the S&P 500, the basic idea can be shown, deliberately without it being a real trading opportunity. The market moves into a zone with institutional trading interest, forms a reversal candle and rises again. You enter long. The stop sensibly belongs below the last low, the first target at the price where the market has bounced several times already. That gives you a clearly defined risk and a reward-to-risk ratio of about 1.5.

Now what every trader knows happens: the market briefly dips below the low, takes your stop and then rises after all. With every trade, it pays to ask how far it may run against you until you have to admit you were wrong. If the market builds volume below the low and breaks out, the idea is refuted, and you leave the trade. If it was only a short excursion, the question remains whether that was really the moment you were wrong. From a risk management perspective in directional trading, the stop belongs there anyway, and it has to be as small as possible to achieve a good reward-to-risk ratio.

With the option, the approach looks different. Instead of buying the future, you sell a put option on the future further down. You are the option writer and collect a premium that is credited to you when you sell. In return, you grant the buyer the right to sell you the future at this price, the strikeThe price the right of the option refers to., until expiration. In the imagined scenario, the market is at 6,052 points and the strike is at 6,040. As long as the market stays above the strike and the put is worthless at expiration, the buyer has no reason to use the right: they can sell in the market at a higher price. The option expires, and you keep the entire premium. That also applies if your assessment was wrong and the market did not rise.

5-minute chart of the S&P 500 E-mini future (ES) with red hand drawings: an outlined zone, the entry circled at a reversal candle, a short line below the last low as the stop, further down a line labeled “Put Stillhalter” (short put) as the strike, a vertical line for the option's expiration and a zigzag line for an assumed sideways move above the strike.
Oliver's hand-drawn scheme on the 5-minute chart of the ES (S&P 500 future, March 2025 contract): entry and stop of the futures trade, below it the strike of the sold put and the expiration of the option. In the imagined scenario, the market is at 6,052 points and the strike at 6,040. A scheme, not a real trading opportunity. From minute 28:44. Image: WH SelfInvest Deutschland

So you are not speculating that price rises from your entry but that it does not fall to the strike by expiration. The market would have to run very far to get you into trouble at all. That is a completely different idea from catching the ideal moment to make profits as quickly as possible. The other side of the trade does not necessarily have to be a loser: there can be winners on both sides of a trade, because you do not know the other party's intention.

The big disadvantage: the profit is capped at the premium. If the market explodes in your direction, a directional trade would have brought clearly more, and that annoys an inexperienced trader. Set against this: anyone who knows what they are doing, how and where they sell options and with what time to expiration, can see a clearly higher hit rate and trading that is more pleasant in everyday life. “You are capped at the premium, but you get it back with the hit rates and have a much more pleasant, relaxed time in everyday life,” says Oliver Sparing. The entry then often forgives more: the market may run slightly against you, and you still leave the trade as a winner. A directional trade, by contrast, must not reach the stop level and ideally has to run in your direction right away. Both the hit rate and that forgiveness, however, depend on strike, time to expiration and risk management. The price for it is stated above: a profit that never exceeds the premium, and a loss that very well can.

The following table summarizes the comparison. It refers to sold options, not to options in general:

CriterionDirectional futures tradeShort put or call option
Market expectationPrice has to run in your direction.Price should not reach the strike by expiration, so it should not run far against you.
Cap on profitThe instrument itself does not cap the profit.The profit is at most the premium collected.
Loss profileThe loss is limited by the stop as long as it is executed; price gaps are possible.The loss tends to be larger than the premium, even with a spread. On an uncovered call it is theoretically unlimited; on an uncovered put it can run until price falls to zero.
Effect of timeTime alone brings neither profit nor loss.Time decay works for the seller, but price and implied volatility also affect the option price.
Role of the stopThe stop sits tight below or above the entry and is the core of the reward-to-risk ratio.The position gives more room but does not replace an exit plan: stops, spreads and closing manually are part of it.
07

A recorded bear call spread in the S&P 500

The example is one of Oliver Sparing's own trades from the days before the webinar, deliberately one that did not work out as hoped. On the screen, you see the 5-minute chart, the footprint chart, the heatmap and an excerpt of the trading platform with the position. The trade ran on the SPX, the S&P 500 index, whose options settle in cash: no future is delivered. The chart analysis comes from the ES future; at entry, the ES stood at about 6,080 points.

Shortly after the opening of the US session, the market, after a move down, is in a zone where, by the analysis behind the trade, market makers in the options markets have to adjust open hedges. To do so, they mainly sell the underlying and tend to push the market down. That is why this zone is where short entries are sought.

The entry is a bear call spread. According to the platform line (SPX Jan29 6105/6140), a call with a 6,105 strike was sold and, for protection, a call at 6,140 was bought; expiration is January 29, 2025. The buyer of the sold call is entitled to the amount by which the SPX is above 6,105 at expiration, settled in cash. If the index ends below that, the right expires worthless. The premium collected was $141.80 after fees, which is also the maximum profit. By calculation, the spread's maximum risk is 35 points × $100 − $141.80 = $3,358.20, or a good 23 times the premium. That shows that the option writer's risk of loss is larger than the possible profit even with a spread. The software continuously shows how far the trade is in profit or loss, relative to the premium collected.

In fast forward, the example plays out like this. First, the market briefly moves in the desired direction, then against the position. With a directional trade and a stop above the last high, the trade would have been stopped out, although the market was still in the downtrend, in the zone and below the VWAP, and the idea was unchanged. With the spread, the trade is only slightly in the red. That leaves time to wait and judge how far the market may run at most before the trade idea is no longer intact.

Trading platform with the position line “SPX Jan29 6105/6140 Bear…” and an open result of minus 15 dollars (minus 10.3 percent of the premium), below it the 5-minute chart, footprint and heatmap of the ES at about 6,080 points, chart dated January 29, 2025.
The position is slightly in the red: −$15, or −10.3% of the premium. Below it, the 5-minute chart, footprint and heatmap of the ES, which stands at about 6,080 points (chart dated 01/29/2025). A single historical example, not a typical result. From minute 40:10. Image: WH SelfInvest Deutschland

The market then runs to the edge of the zone and to the VWAP, the resistance holds, and the market rejects the area and falls back. Had it broken above and stabilized, the trade would have been closed at that point to limit the risk. The loss would then probably still have been below 60 to 70% of the premium. Instead, the market falls again, and the position is in profit with the ES around 6,080 points, at the same price level where it had been in the red before.

The same position on the trading platform with an open result of plus 12 dollars (plus 8.3 percent of the premium); the ES is again at about 6,080 points.
The same position at about the same ES price, now +$12 (+8.3% of the premium) in profit. A single historical example, not a typical result. From minute 44:40. Image: WH SelfInvest Deutschland

One reason is time valueThe part of the option price that shrinks as expiration approaches. That works for the seller, but price movement and implied volatility also affect the price and can cancel the effect.: it shrinks over time, and that works for the seller. For this trade, the chance of still becoming a loser fell with every minute. That holds for this one example, not as a law: price movement and implied volatility also affect the option price and can cancel the time value effect. If price did not move at all, a directional trade would neither win nor lose, while the sold option would rise in value through time decay.

Later comes the breakout that had been awaited, but it turns out to be a false breakout. The market reacts at the level, and buyers return. The trade idea is no longer intact, and the position is closed: up 31% of the premium, $44, with the ES back around 6,080, the level of the entry. The trade ends in profit, although from a directional point of view the original idea did not work out most of the time, and it was never under great pressure. The value of the example lies not in the profit but in how a trade behaves that does not immediately do what you expected. Oliver Sparing sums it up: “It is more pleasant, it forgives more, it gives you more room, more time to think, to reflect and to look at what the market is showing you right now and how you want to react to it.” It remains a single historical example. Had the market kept pushing against the position, an exit would have been necessary, and the risk was, as calculated above, well above the premium.

08

Zero-DTE options in conversation

The time decay of the short position can be used to withstand smaller moves in the wrong direction. This has only been possible in this form for a short time: since 2022, there have been zero-DTE optionsOptions with zero days to expiration: they expire on the day of trading. that expire daily. Oliver Sparing trades classic statistical zero-DTE options with fixed rules in parallel and now also does a large part of his trades with zero-DTE options. That came about more by chance: he ran his conventional futures trades statistically alongside zero-DTE options for comparison and at some point traded both in parallel. He stayed with zero-DTE options because it is so pleasant for him, especially for people with a job, even though he made more money with futures.

One difference from the future: with the option, the profit is capped from the start, whereas with the future it can theoretically rise without limit. In return, the future has the stop-outs at important points such as round numbers on the chart, for example when the market first breaks out, then comes back and takes the stop and afterwards runs the typical move. With the option, such a swing is easier to withstand, as long as the position does not run too far into the red. Because you continuously see how the position develops, you can also pull the plug at any time and be content with a smaller profit instead of waiting for the entire premium.

09

The downside: risk and protection

This has to be learned, and it takes experience, especially when it goes against you. With option writing, you tend to always have a larger risk of loss than the profit you can potentially collect, even if you protect yourself with a spread. You therefore have to stay objective. If the market moves into an area where the trade no longer makes sense, you take it out manually and think: next time it will work better.

The classic mistake is to hope that the market will still come your way. Then a trade in which you collected a premium can turn into a loss that is a multiple of the premium and that first has to be earned back. That is the downside of the whole thing: you have to stay honest, act on what the market shows you and protect yourself sensibly with stops and spreads. That is part of options trading.

With zero-DTE options, time decay works even faster, but that is put into perspective by the fact that you still have to be right about the direction. Anyone who has sold a call and counts on it expiring worthless can be wrong: if the market rises, it can rise without limit. That belongs on your radar to pull the plug in time. Part of the art lies there.

10

What you can take away from the webinar

  • Futures and options start at different points. The future lives on its stop and reward-to-risk ratio, the sold option on the premium, time value and a tendency toward a higher hit rate. The premium pays for an obligation and a risk; it is not proof of a profitable system.
  • The sold option often leaves more room in the entry. A trade can run against you for a while and still end in profit, because time value shrinks. How much room you get depends on strike, time to expiration and risk management, and price movement and volatility also affect the price. In return, the profit is capped at the premium.
  • The option writer's risk of loss is larger than their possible profit. That stays true even with a spread: in the recorded example, the maximum risk was a good 23 times the premium by calculation. A trade in which you collected a premium can end in the red with a multiple of it if you do not exit in time. Stops and spreads are part of it.
  • Only trade what you have understood. The option is a complex instrument. Find the trading style that fits you, your time and your capital.

“You always have to stay objective and say: when the market moves into an area where I say, okay, my trade no longer makes sense here, then I really have to take it out manually, too.”

Oliver Sparing in the WH SelfInvest webinar (translated from German)
11

About the webinar

The webinar ran as part of the WH SelfInvest webinar series and is published on the YouTube channel of WH SelfInvest Deutschland. It was hosted by Stefan Fröhlich of WH SelfInvest. WH SelfInvest is a broker. The webinar is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on machine-translated subtitles. Oliver is a regular guest there; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Note: the webinar is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Trading futures and options involves high risks, and everyone trades at their own risk. The video is a recording from 2025. What it announces as upcoming may look different today; brand, company and product names as well as references to training programmes and ways to get in touch reflect the status at that time.

Day trading programme
Which trading approach fits your daily life?
Whether you trade futures or options, entry, stop and risk have to fit your time and your capital. In our day trading programme, you learn to align them. The programme is currently offered in German.
Day trading programme (German)
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between futures and options in day trading?

With a future, you speculate directionally on the price, protect yourself with a stop and aim for a good reward-to-risk ratio. With a sold option, you collect a premium and speculate that price will not reach a certain level anymore. That can lead to a higher hit rate and forgives more mistakes in the entry; whether it works out depends on strike, time to expiration and risk management. The profit stays capped at the premium.

What is the downside of selling options?

The profit is capped at the premium from the start, whereas the option writer's risk of loss tends to be larger than that profit: theoretically unlimited on an uncovered call, and down to a price of zero on an uncovered put. Even with a spread, the risk stays larger than the possible profit; in the recorded example, it was by calculation a good 23 times the premium. On top of that, the option is a complex instrument that you have to have understood.

Why can an options trade end in profit even though the market runs against the position for a while?

Over time, the time value of the sold option shrinks, and that works for the seller. If price moves sideways, a directional trade would neither win nor lose, while the sold option gains from time value. Price movement and implied volatility also affect the option price, though, and can cancel the effect. In the recorded bear call spread on the SPX, the position was slightly in the red for a while (−$15), where a tight stop in the future would already have been hit, and later moved into profit. That is a single historical example, not a typical result.

How do you protect sold options?

Stops and spreads are part of options trading. It also helps to stay objective and to close a trade manually when the trade idea no longer holds, instead of hoping that the market will still turn.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances

Day Trading or Swing Trading: What Fits You?

Day Trading or Swing Trading: What Fits You?

A silver pocket watch and a sundial sit side by side on a dark table.
VideoWH SelfInvest webinar

Day Trading or Swing Trading:
What Fits You?

Day trading and swing trading differ in more than how long a trade runs. Time commitment, capital, ongoing costs, data sources and learning effort also look different in the two disciplines. Which one suits you depends less on the market than on your daily life and your temperament.

Two ways of measuring time, both equally valid. Which fits you depends on your daily life.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

Day trading and swing trading differ in holding period, time commitment, capital, costs, data sources and learning effort. In day trading, you close every trade on the same day and decide at the screen; in swing trading, you plan with more time and rely on fundamental data. Which discipline fits depends on your character, your risk profile and your time.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 15

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: WH SelfInvest DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

The comparison at a glance

Six criteria separate the two disciplines most clearly. The table summarizes them, and the sections below explain the background.

CriterionDay tradingSwing trading
Holding periodOpen and close on the same dayTwo days to about three months (working definition in the webinar)
Time for planning and monitoringDecisions during trading hours at the screen, one or two ticks matterPlanning and analysis before entry, less price-sensitive, no constant screen watching
Capital and riskRisk per trade can be kept small, less time in the market; prop firms as an additional routeWider stops, higher risk per contract, exposed for longer; own capital (guideline in the webinar: a five-figure account, at least 10,000)
Ongoing costsData feed and order flow software; much higher data fees as a professionalData and software for fundamental analysis, usually much lower
Typical data sourcesOrder book, order flow and market data, evaluated at your discretionFundamental data such as the CoT report, seasonal patterns and term structure in commodities
Learning effortMuch practice at the screen required, hard workTextbook factors of technical analysis and fundamental data work better, less screen time
03

The time horizon: days or hours

The most obvious difference is time in the market. In day trading, you open a trade on one day and close it again on the same day; whether it lasts a minute or ten hours does not matter at first. In swing tradingTrading over several days up to about three months (working definition from the webinar): you hold a position until a price target or your stop is reached., you trade on a medium-term basis. The webinar works with a holding period of roughly two days to three months, depending on strategy and trading instrument. What goes beyond that is considered position tradingTrading with very long holding periods that go beyond about three months..

Swing trading leaves more time: you can plan a trade, analyze and evaluate data before you open, and you proceed in a much less price-sensitive way. Whether you get in one or two ticks better or worse usually makes no big difference to a swing trader; in day trading, it can make all the difference in the world. Swing trading is also usually psychologically more relaxed: whoever does not sit in front of the screen all day interferes less often, and less needlessly, with a running trade.

The flip side of a longer time horizon is risk: whoever stays in a trade longer can be caught by an unforeseen event such as a black swanA rare, hardly predictable event that moves markets strongly.. You want to be protected against that, and that means knowing what you are doing at all times.

04

Capital: equity as a basis

For capital, the instruments matter. Whoever trades standardized, regulated markets such as futuresStandardized futures contracts traded on futures exchanges with fixed contract sizes. and options depends on their minimum sizes: on the marginThe collateral the broker requires in the account for an open position. the broker requires and on an account balance that has to fit risk and money management. Otherwise, the account is done after two or three trades.

In swing trading, you generally trade with your own money: you need a funded live account with sufficient capital and have to be willing to put it to work. With large commodity futures, the risk per contract is often high, because the stops in swing trading are further away. One way to ease this is micro futuresSmaller contracts of common futures with a fraction of the contract size. Risk and margin depend on the specific product and on the broker.: smaller contracts that the CME introduced for large, liquid markets. A small account is not enough by itself, though, because risk and margin depend on the specific product and on the broker (CME on micro futures).

An alternative is options trading. It is the most complex trading instrument, but once understood, it can be tailored to the size of the account. Only suitably structured strategies limit the risk from the outset, for example certain spreads (OCC on spreads). Even spreads can carry additional execution and assignment risks.

05

Capital in day trading

In day trading, the classic way is also your own capital, and smaller amounts often suffice there: you can push the risk per trade down much further, for example with micro futures. In return, you spend less time in the market, whereas in swing trading you are exposed to risk for longer. You should factor in this difference.

What amount you need depends on the market, the instrument and your risk per trade. A demo account can make sense for learning, but at the end of the day, it should be your own capital.

For day traders, there is an additional route in the form of prop trading firms: you apply, take an exam and are given an account, usually a demo account. You should watch out for that. Part of the profits goes to the provider, and you follow its rules. You should clarify the tax treatment of such payouts with a tax advisor in advance. For first experience, this can be a route, but the goal remains a different one: “The goal should always be to trade with your own money in the long run and to work with a reasonable broker,” says Oliver Sparing.

06

Costs for data and software

Ongoing costs are quickly forgotten. In day trading, especially in order flowThe analysis of the orders actually executed and waiting in the order book, to read the behavior of market participants. and order book trading, you need a data feed and good tools. For retail traders, the price data for futures exchanges are moderate; whoever trades as a professional, for example through a company, pays clearly more. On top of that comes software, which costs money if it is to be good.

In swing trading, you also need data and software, above all for fundamental analysis. The costs are usually much lower than in day trading. Plan these ongoing items from the start anyway, just as you plan your trading capital.

07

Approach in swing trading: fundamental data

When it comes to approach, swing trading and day trading are worlds apart. The longer you are in the trade, the more influence fundamental factors have, meaning everything that happens in the world. That is an advantage because this data can be evaluated and used.

Oliver Sparing comes from commodity trading. Valuing a stock seriously means dealing with the business, management, industry, sector and balance sheet, and that is time-consuming. Whether this beats an ETF on a broad index is not certain. In commodity trading, by contrast, very specific data are available that can be followed and evaluated, which makes the analysis more manageable. They are not a holy grail of trading: they give you a well-founded starting position, but not a certain trade.

These include the CoT reportThe weekly report by the US agency CFTC that shows how different trader groups are positioned in the futures markets., which the US agency CFTC publishes once a week and which shows what, for instance, the producers of a commodity are doing at the moment, seasonal patterns, such as beef prices that usually rise at the start of the US grilling season, and the term structureThe course of the prices of a commodity across different delivery dates; it gives hints about supply and demand., from which you can tell how the supply of a commodity stands. That does not mean you buy right away. They are building blocks for your decision.

08

Approach in day trading: statistical or discretionary

In day trading, market data take the place of economic data. It is a world of its own, for people who like working with numbers. “Day trading is something you only learn if you really burn for it,” says Oliver Sparing. That applies above all to order book trading. It is like piano lessons: whoever attends them reluctantly will not learn the instrument, whoever absolutely wants to play it has a chance.

In day trading, there are two major approaches. With statistical tradingTrading by a fixed rule set that can be modeled mathematically and algorithmically., you follow fixed rules: if A, B and C happen, you do D. That can be modeled mathematically and algorithmically. It still works but has become harder over the years because many algorithms are active in the market. A system often works only for a limited time; the webinar speaks of two to three months, with luck half a year. Then the edge is gone, and the next strategy is needed. A mere crossing of two moving averages no longer does the job, a system should have market logic behind it.

With discretionary tradingTrading in which you evaluate objective market data and make the decision yourself based on your experience., which many professional traders follow, you collect objective data and indications from the market. You evaluate them with your head, though, and trade on the basis of experience and, with all caution, an intuition that develops over many hours at the screen. That is not a gut feeling in the usual sense.

09

Asset classes: regulated markets and OTC

For asset classes, it helps to look at how the price comes about. On one side are regulated exchanges with standardized contracts and a visible order book, for example for futures, stocks, ETFs and options. On the other side are products whose price a provider quotes: CFDs and over-the-counter trading (OTCOver the counter: trading outside an exchange, where you enter the transaction directly with a provider rather than on an exchange with a visible order book.). You enter CFDs directly with the provider. Certificates and warrants exist both over the counter and on an exchange (Deutsche Börse on certificates and warrants), so they are not OTC products across the board.

On an exchange, prices and the order book are visible to everyone. Which price you get, however, depends on the execution and timing of your order (SEC on order execution). The markets that professional traders also trade serve as a point of orientation: aligning yourself with those who earn money on the exchange is rarely a bad idea.

With CFDs, certificates and warrants, it pays to differentiate strongly. With a CFD, it depends on the provider and the fair price. Whoever combines a lack of knowledge and a trading system without a foundation with such products quickly harms themselves. The webinar therefore recommends futures, stocks, ETFs and options. You should not confuse options with warrants, though, as these are two different financial products.

10

Options and training

In the conversation, options are called the Champions League of trading, and the host advises getting trained before trading them. Oliver Sparing had to pass a demanding options test at his own broker.

Trading is a profession like any other, and as in any profession, sound training pays off, especially in day trading. We are happy if you come to TradeNeon, but there are other reputable providers as well.

11

Complexity and learning effort

When it comes to learning effort, swing trading has advantages. The rough textbook factors of technical analysis work better there, fundamental data are available, it is psychologically less demanding, and you do not have to sit at the computer and actively trade working time for money. “For all the doubters out there who are not quite sure where they belong: go for swing trading,” says Oliver Sparing.

Day trading, by contrast, demands a lot of practice. A coach can show how to hold the guitar and strike the strings, and how the markets work, but the practicing remains hard work and takes perseverance.

A fundamental pattern runs through both disciplines: trading is very individual, and what works for one trader does not work for another by itself. More important than a ready-made strategy is therefore a broad understanding of how the markets work and why you do what you do: auction and price formation mechanisms, tools, theoretical foundations. Building on that, you find the system that fits your character, your risk profile and your time. Many people look for the formula that always works, or for the golden buy button. It matters more to know what you are doing.

12

Algorithms and AI: who moves the price?

One point matters most for choosing a trading style: a purely statistical approach by a mathematical rule set competes with algorithms that also trade by fixed rules. Whoever interprets market data at their own discretion becomes largely independent of them.

“The high-frequency algorithms certainly account for a large part of the trading volume, but they are not the ones moving the price. The ones who move the price are still the large institutions or the commercial traders,” says Oliver Sparing. As a small speculator, these are the participants you can orient yourself by. Machine learning is considered an exciting field, but a kind of AI that you only have to switch on and that then trades by a rule set was not in sight at the time of the webinar.

13

What you can take away from the webinar

  • The holding period is the first difference. In day trading, you open and close on the same day and trade more price-sensitively. In swing trading, you hold trades for two days to about three months, by the working definition in the webinar, and have more time to plan.
  • Capital, costs and instruments are part of the decision. What amount you need depends on the market, the instrument and the risk per trade, and micro futures, options and prop firms each come with their own conditions and risks. On top of that come ongoing costs for data and software.
  • The approach differs. In swing trading, you rely on fundamental data such as the CoT report, which gives you a well-founded starting position but not a certain trade. In day trading, you evaluate market data statistically or discretionarily.
  • Which discipline fits depends on you. Character, risk profile and time decide. A broad understanding of the market comes before any ready-made strategy.

“You have to be clear that trading is a very, very individual matter.”

Oliver Sparing in the WH SelfInvest webinar (translated from German)
14

About the webinar

The webinar ran in February 2024 as a webinar by WH SelfInvest and was published on the YouTube channel of WH SelfInvest Deutschland. WH SelfInvest is a broker. The host was Stefan Fröhlich. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on machine-translated subtitles. It was Oliver's first time as a guest in this series. The format was interactive, with polls and questions from the chat. Two points from Oliver's agenda, risk and expectations, were left for another time because of time constraints. You can find all of Oliver's appearances on our guest appearances page.

How both disciplines feel in everyday life is described in our article Which Trading Style Fits Your Life?.

Note: the video is a recording from 2024. Brand and company names as well as information on costs and offers in the video reflect the status at that time.

Day trading and swing trading programmes
Which programme fits your time?
Whether day trading or swing trading fits your time, your temperament and your capital is worth thinking through carefully. In our programmes, you learn how both work. The programmes are currently offered in German.
Programmes (German)
Frequently asked questions
What distinguishes day trading and swing trading in holding period?

In day trading, you open and close a trade on the same day, whether it lasts a minute or ten hours. In swing trading, you hold it between two days and about three months, by the working definition in the webinar. What goes beyond that is rather considered position trading.

Do I need more capital for day trading or swing trading?

That depends on the market, the instrument and the risk per trade. In day trading, you can push the risk per trade down much further, for example with micro futures, but you spend less time in the market. Micro futures are smaller contracts, but a small account is not enough by itself, because risk and margin depend on the specific product and on the broker. In swing trading, you are exposed to risk for longer, the stops are further away, and the webinar names a five-figure account, at least 10,000, as a guideline. In day trading, prop firms come in as an additional route, and in the long run, trading with your own money at a solid broker is the goal. Which amount fits your situation, we clarify in the strategy call.

Why do fundamental data play a bigger role in swing trading?

The longer you are in a trade, the more influence fundamental factors have on the price. In swing trading, you can use them, for example the CoT report, seasonal patterns or the term structure in commodity trading. They give you a well-founded starting position, but not a certain trade.

What is the difference between statistical and discretionary day trading?

With statistical trading, you follow a fixed rule set that can be modeled mathematically and algorithmically. With discretionary trading, you evaluate objective market data with your head and trade on the basis of your experience. Many professional traders proceed discretionarily today.

Are certificates and warrants OTC products?

Not across the board. Certificates and warrants exist both over the counter and on an exchange. CFDs, by contrast, you enter directly with the provider that quotes the price. Regulated exchanges offer standardized contracts and a visible order book, for example for futures, stocks, ETFs and options. Options should not be confused with warrants.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances