Oliver Sparing in an Interview: Order Flow and Swing Trading

Oliver Sparing in an Interview: Order Flow and Swing Trading

Two upholstered armchairs face each other, with a studio microphone on a boom arm between them.
VideoInterview

Oliver Sparing in an Interview:
Order Flow and
Swing Trading

Knowledge and hard work beat talent, and Oliver Sparing is proof of that. In day trading, his day begins with market analysis, only then does the order book confirm the plan, and in swing trading his portfolio is spread across several strategies. The interview at Insider Trading is about his path from commodities to order flow and the routine that grew out of it.

A long conversation about one path into trading, without shortcuts.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

The trading day in order flow day trading begins with the market analysis: dark pool data, CME SPAN data, options data and dealer hedging produce zones in which institutional interest is likely to sit. At the level, the order book confirms the plan, and a setup should be statistically evaluable. In swing trading, the portfolio is spread across several strategies, CoT data and seasonality form a foundation, the entry comes from the chart, and risk stays conservative.

01

The video

The video is in German. For English audio, open the settings (gear icon) in the player and choose Audio track → English.

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 27

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: Insider TradingMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

Oliver's path to trading

Oliver comes from the commodities field. Around 2010 and 2011, he engages with the exchange; professionally, he trades physical investment metals such as coins and bars at the time, not on an exchange.

He loses his first CFD account on the first evening, and that becomes the occasion to learn the exchange from the ground up. Swing trading and options trading follow, the first discipline in which things worked out for him. Later, day trading and order book and order flow trading are added, today his hobbyhorses. Alongside, he continues to trade options, including zero-DTE options, as well as futures, commodities and stocks.

He learned the craft of day trading on a trading floor in London. Oliver was no natural talent: he had to work hard for much of it, and it took a long time until he became profitable. Because he is an emotional person, he adapts positions and risk to his character.

Many younger people today start with CFDs and crypto. Whoever has no personal contact with the exchange first meets the loudest providers, like the advertising boards at the edge of the pitch in a football stadium. Back then, the path led to exchange-regulated instruments such as stocks, futures and options, because there you do not, when in doubt, trade against your own broker. Today, the choice of brokers is larger, and there are many good CFD and crypto brokers.

03

Where a trade is worth considering

The day in order flow day trading begins with an extensive market analysis. It is important to understand which setups you trade, and at least as important where you trade them. For that, Oliver evaluates several data sources every morning: data from dark pools, the CME's SPANThe risk model that futures exchanges such as the CME use to calculate margin requirements. A risk interval around the closing price can be derived from it. data, options data and dealer hedging data, plus the liquidity in the order book as well as volume profiles and market profiles.

The combination produces zones in which institutional interest is likely to sit. This gives the plan for the day: where trades come into question, where not (at least as important) and in which direction. “Market analysis is the be-all and end-all. You never want to trade somewhere in the middle of nowhere,” says Oliver Sparing. He still does the analysis by hand. TradeNeon's software is a mirror of it: it brings the levels into the charts of various platforms.

Dealer hedging

At the center is dealer hedgingMarket makers hedge their options positions in the underlying and adjust this hedge continuously.. On the other side of an options trade usually sits a market makerMarket participants who continuously quote buy and sell prices and want to live off the spread rather than the direction of price.. They do not want to buy cheap and sell higher but to profit from the spread and get rid of the trade again immediately. If that does not work, they have directional risk and neutralize it in the underlying, for example in the S&P 500 future. Because the option does not move in the same rhythm as the underlying, they have to adjust this hedge continuously. Models can be used to estimate where market makers are positioned and under what circumstances they would have to buy or sell.

CoT data are relevant in the medium to longer term and bring no edge in intraday trading. Dealer hedging, by contrast, offers possible price zones for the trading day. It remains a working hypothesis: market makers have great influence, but the other market participants know their constraints as well. Whether a zone holds only becomes clear at the level. Placing a limit order blindly at a level and hoping for the best does not work for that reason. A stop has to fit the day's volatility, and an unexpected piece of news can run it over. That is why you need a setup at the level.

Icon of the dealer hedging course
Dealer hedging course
Understand dealer hedging from the ground up
Learn about options, the Greeks and how possible hedging areas are calculated. The course uses examples from options, stocks and futures. It is currently taught in German.
Explore the course in German

What happens in the order book

When the market comes to a previously defined level, Oliver looks into the order book. Heatmap and classic order book both have their use; he works a lot with the heatmapThe heatmap shows the order book over time: where limit orders sat and how large they were. and combines the two views. What he watches is how liquidity shifts, where orders are filled, where new ones come in, where rebalancing takes place and how the delta changes. The order book is meant to confirm the plan made beforehand.

There is no clear trigger in day trading that says “buy.” What you see in the order book has to be interpreted. The point is not to get lost in market understanding and to end up with a repeatable setup whose statistical edge you have evaluated. More aggressive entries and waiting for more confirmation both have their price: whoever waits for more confirmation gives up some of the reward-to-risk ratio. The range can become extreme, all the way to unprofitability. That is why statistics matter: whether a setup has an edge only becomes clear through evaluation.

With AI, it is now conceivable to implement such strategies algorithmically, with caution. One advantage in discretionary day trading, however, can lie precisely in the room for human interpretation, which makes you independent of the classic algorithms in the market.

The five factors in order flow

  • Passive market participants How do limit orders shift in the order book, where are they filled, where does spoofingLarge orders that are placed in the order book and removed again before execution in order to influence the market. take place?
  • Active market participants Who moves the market with market orders, and is there a shift in delta?
  • Market and auction speed This is easier to observe in the classic order book. Does the market start to “wriggle”?
  • Order flow events AbsorptionLarge amounts of aggressive orders are taken up by limit orders without price moving on., stop run, exhaustion, sweeps.
  • Price action In the microstructure, it is at least as relevant as on a daily or monthly chart.

What is decisive is that these processes take place at price zones that are relevant for institutions. Only a small part of what constantly happens in the market is usable. Beginners especially see an opportunity around every corner after the first concepts such as absorption or iceberg orders.

04

At the level, the reaction is what counts

Oliver trades the US session, above all the first one to two hours after the open in New York and the last two trading hours. He trades almost exclusively the ES future, the S&P 500 future. In the past, it was also the gold and crude oil futures. For the ES, he has the most data that give him an additional edge.

First, he looks at his picture of the market: hourly and four-hour chart, which higher-level market phase the market is in, how it reacted to his levels. Then he works out a plan and sets an alert at the next relevant price level. A common beginner mistake is to sit in front of it and drive yourself crazy because you see an opportunity around every corner. He waits patiently until the market comes to the zone and then watches the order book.

For that, he uses a classic candlestick chart on 5 minutes, “a good old 5-minute chart.” A 1-minute or 15-minute chart is just as fine. On top come a market profile and a volume profile to follow auction methods and market structure. In practice, he works with a combination of Bookmap and TradingView. For order book data, you need live market data from the exchange and software such as Bookmap or Quantower, combined with a data feed.

Oliver steers clear of news releases. He is no news trader but knows there are strong ones. Shortly before important US economic data, market makers pull liquidity out of the order book: in the heatmap, a wall of orders suddenly disappears. A few minutes after the release, the liquidity gradually comes back, and then he trades again. Classic order book trading largely leaves the realm of economics anyway; market mechanics play the role here. The longer term a trade is meant to be, the more fundamental factors count.

05

In swing trading, the portfolio comes first

Order flow day trading takes a longer familiarization period, and you have to confirm for yourself that your own approach has an edge, ideally through statistics. Whoever has not proven for themselves that it works has a hard time psychologically, because doubts keep coming back. In swing trading, things are often calmer, and approaches are easier to replicate and teach. Anyone who decides on a day trading programme also brings a certain stress factor into their life and should have a great interest in the markets. “I am absolutely no fan of this credo, trade like a machine. We are not machines, we are human beings. We have emotions, and we have to learn to deal with them,” says Oliver Sparing. When he notices that he is reacting more emotionally, he does not day trade in that phase.

Several strategies instead of one

Oliver builds his trading portfolio like a long-term stock portfolio: with diversification, meaning with several strategies that correlate as little as possible. Whoever relies on only one can go through a bad phase over a longer period. He has seen this himself with classic income strategies using options on the ES future and the SPX. For a start, however, it is important to learn one strategy properly first and to broaden out only afterwards. In swing trading, he works with four building blocks.

  • Commodity trading with CoT data The theoretical foundation is CoT data, seasonal patterns and term structure, combined with a setup that is logical in terms of market technicals.
  • Strategy on the 4-hour chart It combines market structure and auction logic with Fibonacci retracements.
  • Three stock strategies His own indicators pre-filter stocks by various criteria. He then enters on momentum or on pullbacks.
  • Options strategies Options strategies are the fourth building block.

Swing trading is his “bread and butter.” How day and swing trading are distributed among clients fluctuates: sometimes there is more interest in one, sometimes in the other. Some add day trading after a while; others notice in day trading that it stresses them too much and switch to swing trading.

CoT data and own indicators

In commodities, CoT data are a base filter, comparable to the market analysis in day trading. Oliver has developed his own indicators that go beyond the classic Larry Williams index. The index looks at the net position, and a purely absolute view of positioning can say little. The data are therefore put in relation to total open interestThe number of all open contracts in a futures market., producers and processors are looked at separately, and the positioning is also put in relation to price. On top of that, it counts how many institutions hold a position: a high open interest held by only a few is less meaningful than one spread across many. The absolute view runs as a dry powderAn indicator of how much room a positioning still has before it is historically stretched. indicator; the relative one through an OBOS framework.

Alone, this usually gives no edge. It gives a good fundamental starting position in which a suitable setup then makes sense. Because CoT trading is usually trading against a strong trend, and a trend is more likely to continue than to reverse, it takes patience and a sensible setup. The wait is for a prominent volume peak in the volume profile and for the market to break out of it against the trend direction for the first time. The value of CoT data lies less in finding good entries than in finding trades with a lot of potential in the desired direction when the market moves. How CoT data work in principle is explained in detail in the video article on the ATAS webinar.

On the question of which trader group counts: the commercials have the most expertise about their market, but their intention has become less clear because they speculate more today than they used to. With managed moneySpeculative large investors in the disaggregated CoT report, such as hedge funds., the intention is clearer. In the evaluations the TradeNeon team has done over the years, the positioning of this speculative group showed the highest correlation with price. The thought behind dry powder: if everyone who was historically long is already long, who is left to buy?

Seasonality

On seasonality in commodities, the indicators determine the patterns on the basis of adjusted contracts (back-adjustmentPrices of old contracts are adjusted for the roll gaps so that a continuous chart results.), because roll gaps between contracts would otherwise distort a pattern. At the start of the year, the patterns of all relevant markets are reviewed, determined algorithmically, ten years back. Interesting are patterns lasting on average about ten trading days, up to a month. With longer ones, you have to expect corrections. Over the ten-year period, the market should have moved in the direction of the seasonality in at least nine of the last ten years, and the evaluation is market-specific: a volatile market cannot be equated with a calm one.

A seasonality is one fundamental factor among several and, just like CoT data, not a pure entry trigger. What is sought are entries based on auction logic, with a chart-technical entry. Today Oliver also trades against a seasonality now and then when everything else speaks for a dream setup, which he would not have done a few years ago. For Oliver, seasonalities in commodities play a smaller role today than they did a few years ago.

06

Risk belongs in the plan

On risk, position size always stays very conservative, and Oliver has never leveraged massively, in day trading as in swing trading. His margin is rarely used up far. Because the risk per trade is small, he can have several positions open in parallel in the stock strategies.

“I think trading is a craft. Anyone who is interested and brings a little passion can learn it, up to the point where you earn money with it and are profitable,” says Oliver Sparing. Whether someone wants to live from it alone is a question of type. Oliver would not advise anyone to rely on trading alone too early in their career. A second source of income is entirely legitimate.

As a teacher, he enjoys the work because he can help others move forward. His coaches have all gone through his programme.

At the end, Oliver gives viewers this to take along: “Be patient. The path is worth it, but it can be quite long and rocky, and that is entirely normal. Make sure you stay at it with joy and stay in the demo account as long as possible to gather experience.” Trading has a lot to do with experience and with your own character.

07

What you can take away from the interview

  • The place comes before the setup. First, you determine in the market analysis where institutional interest is likely to sit. Without this plan, a trade has no point of reference.
  • The order book confirms the plan. At the level, it is not the mark alone that decides but what happens in the order book.
  • Statistics show whether a setup works. Whoever has not confirmed for themselves that their approach has an edge will have a hard time psychologically.
  • Data such as CoT and seasonality are a foundation. They give a starting position. The entry comes from the setup in the chart.

“What many do not want to admit at the beginning of their trading career is that, as traders, we are first and foremost mathematicians and statisticians.”

Oliver Sparing in the interview at Insider Trading (translated from German)
08

About the interview

The interview appeared on March 29, 2026 on the YouTube channel Insider Trading. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on YouTube's subtitle translation. Everything stated here is Oliver's personal experience and assessment from the conversation. The channel points out that the video is not investment advice and that trading involves considerable risks. Oliver is also a guest with other partners; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Day trading programme
How do you build your own trading routine?
A routine like Oliver's, from market analysis to the order book, is something you build step by step. In our day trading programme, you learn how. The programme is currently offered in German.
Day trading programme (German)
Frequently asked questions
What does a trading day in order flow day trading look like?

It starts with the market analysis: dark pools, SPAN data, options data and dealer hedging produce zones in which institutional interest is likely to sit. When the market comes to such a level, the order book is watched and confirmation of the plan is sought there.

Are CoT data alone enough for a trade?

Usually not. CoT data give a good fundamental starting position but no entry. For that, you need a setup that the market forms at the level, for example the breakout from a volume peak against the trend direction.

What software and data do you need for order flow day trading?

For order book data, you need live market data from the exchange and software such as Bookmap or Quantower in combination with a data feed. In practice, Oliver works with a combination of Bookmap and TradingView.

Is there trading around news releases?

Oliver steers clear of news around important US economic data. Shortly beforehand, market makers pull liquidity out of the order book; a few minutes after the release it comes back, and then he trades again.

Marnie Aramruck
Marnie Aramruck
Founder & Head of Brand & Psychology · TradeNeon
Marnie Aramruck came to trading by an unusual route: ten years self-employed in event management, marketing and design, before turning to the psychology behind decisions. As a master emotion coach and resilience trainer, she now works on a single question: what traders need in order to stay calm and clear even under pressure. Her subject is not the chart, but the person in front of it.

Illusion of Control: Orientation Instead of Certainty

Illusion of Control: Orientation Instead of Certainty

Two hands hold an old steering wheel floating above a dark stone floor.
VideoATAS webinar

Illusion of Control:
Orientation Instead
of Certainty

Anyone who trades wishes for certainty. Trying to get it from the market creates stress: the brain works with predictions, and emotions can be read as feedback on them, not as mistakes. Preparation can be planned, and where certainty is missing, orientation can take its place.

Holding on feels like control. It does not steer the market.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

A statistically tested system and risk management are the foundation, but they do not make the outcome of a single trade controllable. Preparation can be planned, while trading itself takes place in uncertainty, and anyone who demands certainty from the market easily comes under stress. Noticing emotions early, reading them as data and answering consciously in the space between stimulus and response gives orientation.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 22

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: ATAS DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

Why control does not work in trading

Complexity arises faster than you might think: with just ten numbers, there are already 3.6 million possible orders. In trading, market behavior, your own setup, emotions and your form on the day interact. A system like that cannot be controlled in a linear way, with clear causes and effects.

This fits the image that the brain is not a blender. We often look for an instruction manual with buttons so that we are not angry but alert and calm. Anyone who treats themselves like an uncomplicated system should not be surprised when the result differs from what they hoped for.

According to the predictive mind model, the brain can be described as a prediction machine: it serves primarily to secure survival and constantly uses predictions for it. It reacts to deviations and draws on experiences, patterns and also bodily experiences. Behind this there is a second function: the brain wants to expand our world through learning, adaptation, curiosity and exploration.

03

Prediction error: when expectation and reality diverge

If reality does not match the expectation, this model speaks of a prediction errorA prediction error: reality does not match the brain's expectation. It is normal at first and drives learning and adaptation.. It triggers an inner excitation (arousalThe inner excitation a prediction error triggers. It often shows up as an emotional reaction.), often an emotional reaction. An emotion is thus a response to the difference between expectation and reality, and that is not a problem at first. The prediction error drives learning and adaptation. It becomes dangerous when we respond to it with stress.

When does the system tip over? When you do not know what you feel, or when you ignore and suppress the message from your body. “Emotions are helpers in fulfilling needs. When you feel an emotion, there is a reason for it,” says Marnie Aramruck. If an emotion is permanently overridden, it can end in overwhelm and loss of control. The normal cognitive prediction error then turns into an emotional conflict, and in trading that becomes a trap.

One example is fear of an exam the next day. The fear wants to create certainty, and its tactic can be to keep studying. Without fear, you might go into the exam less prepared. So a healthy fear has a task.

04

Stress, tunnel vision and priming

When fear is overridden, perception narrows, as in the Stone Age when a saber-toothed tiger appears: all the energy flows into safety. In trading, this changes the view of the market, and tunnel visionUnder stress, perception narrows. In trading, this changes the view of the market. arises. We then get certainty through thoughts that replace perception: “The market has to rise now” or “This trade has to work now”.

PrimingWhat you experienced beforehand, such as a losing trade, colors the next moment. adds to this: what you experienced beforehand, such as a losing trade, you carry into the next moment and it colors it. Anyone who knows this will recognize it more easily in the next trading hours.

A chart example: on the 5-second chart, a heatmap with Level of Interest shows a bull zone, the idea is a long trade at an important level, with an entry after a small sideways phase. Instead, the market reacts immediately with a V-shaped reversal, without a range. The setup does not form, you do not get into the trade and, in the unfavorable case, you jump in afterward. After the larger move, doubts arise about whether you should have traded after all. That is how the prediction error shows up in trading: the reaction is the answer to a prediction that was held on to. What matters is the change of perspective. Anyone who knows that the brain is complex and the market uncertain, and does not demand certainty from the market, deals with such moments differently.

Heatmap on a 5-second chart with a green zone at the bottom: price falls into the zone and immediately turns up in a V-shaped move.
Chart example from the webinar: the direction was right, but the entry condition never occurred. From minute 25. Image: TradeNeon
05

The illusion of control and what can really be planned

There is structure in trading, but no certainty about how a trade will turn out. The basis is a statistically founded system with backtesting and forward testing, as well as risk management with clear position sizes, stops, profit targets and predefined entries and exits. That says nothing about the individual outcome, but it gives orientation and limits risk. Planning and execution are two different things.

What cannot be controlled is whether a trade turns out positive, how the market reacts and the spontaneous emotional reaction, at least if you are not prepared. Emotions cannot really be controlled, but their intensity can be regulated.

Three illusions of control stand out: the attempt to suppress emotions instead of navigating them, busyness mistaken for self-efficacyThe experience of being able to make something happen yourself. To be set apart from blind busyness, which is only a reaction., and the false sense of security with which people avoid uncertainty. Typical attempts at control belong here: pushing nervousness away, staring at the running trade although an alert can be set at a price level, exiting early, adjusting or leaving it open longer in the hope that the market still turns. These are reactions to fear and not to the system. The thought “this trade has to work now” is also such an attempt, because in trading there are only probabilities and no certainties.

06

Between stimulus and response there is a space

When control falls away, you need neither a new tool nor new rules, but orientation in the midst of uncertainty. System, risk management and rule set must be in place. What then decides is attitude.

The core image: between stimulus and response there is a space, and that is where your freedom begins. The stimulus is, for example, that the market runs through without the expected sideways phase. The reaction can be jumping in afterward or the later agonizing. In the space in between, four things matter: perception, acceptance, empathy and adaptation. Perception means recognizing what is really happening and whether you currently have tunnel vision. Acceptance means that the idea can be right while the setup is not. Adaptation concerns the view of the market and the emotional reaction. Empathy means compassion with yourself, that is, meeting yourself with goodwill and not condemning yourself. All of this can be trained, and it helps decide whether the mouse click at the end is a resilient or a headless reaction.

You hold this space not with control but with a connection to yourself, called self-anchoring. “This is where MindCrafting begins: not control but orientation. That is the attitude we teach,” says Marnie Aramruck.

07

Emotions as a navigation system and source of data

In the model, the brain implements its strategy through emotions, as feedback loops. They show whether a prediction was fulfilled. If it was, pleasant emotions such as joy or gratitude arise. If it was not, for example with fear, the question arises what you can do to gain more certainty. If the prediction error tips into stress, the data have not been read.

Emotion and feeling should be told apart: emotions run unconsciously and translate into bodily sensations. The body is the bridge between mind and emotion. Heartbeat, stomach, muscle tone or sweat can serve as an early warning system, and everyone reacts to them differently.

The widespread maxim “Trade like a machine” has a counterpart in “Trade like MindCrafter”. “I find it really terrible that it is always said: trade like a machine. You are not a robot, and the market is not a robot either. Emotions are not mistakes, they are data,” says Marnie Aramruck. Anyone who does not allow certain emotions cuts themselves off from their energy, from their feedback as a navigation system and from possible coping strategies. One example is anger, whose bright side is self-efficacy. Anyone who does not allow it may find it harder to experience themselves as self-effective and may feel less pride. Anyone who suppresses emotions over a long time may find that pressure builds up, as in a pressure cooker.

Emotional flexibility means being able to switch between states, like babies who are screaming one moment and laughing the next. Adults have often unlearned this. An everyday example: anyone who gets angry in a traffic jam on the way to a meeting can shift their focus or, if it keeps happening, change the strategy and take the train, for example.

08

Training the space: before, during and after the trade

A few questions are worth asking beforehand: what do you currently do to calm yourself, and does it really help? A stress ball during the session can make sense, because emotions do not immediately mean a call to action. If it does not help, a breathing exercise could work. Also: where in your life outside trading are you good at navigating instead of controlling, and what can you transfer from it? Small things are a good way to practice impulse control, such as rules for social media and messengers.

The space can be created at three points in time. Before the trade, you create awareness and do not go into the session too stressed. During trading, you recognize your early warning systems: which emotions come up for you, which block you, when do your hands get sweaty, what calms you? After trading, it is not about judging but about reflecting. Which strategies fit is individual: “It would be totally fatal to say: what works for me works for you. That does not work,” says Marnie Aramruck.

When the space is hard to find, there are three paths. First, one-to-one coaching to resolve blocks, where it is possible to distinguish whether the block lies on the cognitive, emotional or action level. Second, a resilience training that trains exactly these strategies. Third, an open, honest community in which the point is not the biggest trade but questions such as: how do I feel right now, what went wrong, have I tested my system, where is the lever?

09

What you can take away from the webinar

  • Control exists in planning, not in trading itself. System, risk management and rules are the structure. The individual outcome and the market's reaction remain uncertain.
  • Emotions are data. An emotion shows a difference between expectation and reality. Anyone who notices it early can regulate it instead of being overrun by it.
  • The mistake lies in how you deal with it, not in the feeling. Tunnel vision, priming and the thought “it has to work now” color perception.
  • Between stimulus and response there is a space. Perception, acceptance, empathy with yourself and adaptation can be trained, before, during and after the trade.

“Trading does not begin with control, but with the ability to guide yourself through uncertainty. Because between what you plan and what you do lies not weakness but a world that wants to be navigated.”

Marnie Aramruck in the closing words of the webinar (translated from German)
10

About the webinar

The webinar ran on January 15, 2026 on the YouTube channel of ATAS Deutschland, with questions and answers in the chat. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on YouTube's subtitle translation. ATAS is a trading platform for order flow analysis. Marnie Aramruck is the founder of TradeNeon and works as a master emotion coach and resilience trainer on trading psychology. You can find all appearances of Marnie and Oliver on our guest appearances page.

TradeNeon · Trading psychology
How do you deal with uncertainty in trading?
In the MindCrafter programme, you train to stay calm and clear under pressure, structured, practical for everyday life and made for traders. The programme is currently offered in German.
Learn more (German)
Frequently asked questions
What does illusion of control mean in trading?

This means the attempt to create a certainty in trading that the market cannot give. Planning, system and risk management can be controlled, but the outcome of a single trade, the market's reaction and the spontaneous emotional reaction cannot.

So do I not need a system and rules?

You do. A statistically founded system, risk management with clear position sizes, stops and targets, and predefined entries and exits are the basis. This structure gives orientation and limits risk, but it does not give certainty for the individual outcome. On top of that, you need an attitude for the moment of uncertainty.

Are emotions a mistake in trading?

No. Emotions can be understood as a navigation system and source of data. They show that expectation and reality do not match. It becomes a problem when you ignore or suppress them and then follow them impulsively.

What can I do if I act impulsively under pressure?

One approach is to train the space between stimulus and response: create awareness before the trade, recognize early warning signs during trading and reflect instead of judging after the trade. Which strategies suit you is individual. Possible support includes one-to-one coaching, a resilience training and an open community.

Marnie Aramruck
Marnie Aramruck
Founder & Head of Brand & Psychology · TradeNeon
Marnie Aramruck came to trading by an unusual route: ten years self-employed in event management, marketing and design, before turning to the psychology behind decisions. As a master emotion coach and resilience trainer, she now works on a single question: what traders need in order to stay calm and clear even under pressure. Her subject is not the chart, but the person in front of it.

Expirations in Dealer Hedging: Which Time Horizon Counts

Expirations in Dealer Hedging: Which Time Horizon Counts

A blank tear-off calendar hangs beside several loose sheets pinned to a dark wall.
VideoVolland Refined

Expirations in Dealer Hedging:
Which Time Horizon Counts

The same hedging data looks different depending on which expirations you include. For a day trader, different data often matters than for someone holding positions over several days, because options that expire today have to be hedged faster than options with two weeks to run. How vanna zones from the zero-DTE data can be built into the daily plan is shown by examples from the talk at Volland Refined.

Which expirations matter depends on how long you stay in the market.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

Which expirations count depends on your own time horizon: anyone trading within a single day will not rely only on the chart with all expirations, because options that expire today have to be hedged faster by market makers. One possible setup for the day trading horizon is the zero-DTE data, supplemented by the vanna exposure of the next five trading days including today, with a focus on strikes with high exposure, the outer boundaries of the distribution and connected vanna clusters. The data replace neither the analysis in the order book nor do they say for certain how price will react.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 14

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: Wizard of Ops, Volland RefinedMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

Which expirations count for you?

The question Oliver Sparing hears most often from his clients: which data should they look at, and which time horizon takes priority? The dealer hedging concept itself is complex enough, and the choice of data comes on top.

As a thought experiment, picture two vannaOne of the so-called Greeks in options trading that influence the hedging activity of market makers. exposure charts of the same market side by side. One shows only zero-DTEOptions with zero days to expiration: they expire on the day of trading., the other the monthly exposure or even all expirations. The first thing that stands out is the difference in average exposure per strikeThe price the right of the option refers to.: because the longer period includes more data, the absolute sum per strike is clearly higher there.

For a classic day trader or scalper, the chart with all expirations alone is usually not enough, because entirely different forces are at work there. If a market makerA market participant who provides liquidity to the market and takes the other side of trades in return. has built up high exposure at a strike and the option expires today, they have to hedge their delta today. They therefore have to trade faster and more aggressively than with an option that only expires in two weeks.

What matters, then, are the hedging data that fit your own trading horizon, meaning the data with the biggest impact within exactly that time frame. The better the choice fits, the more you can get out of a platform like Volland.

03

The day trading setup with the Volland charts

Oliver Sparing sees himself as a classic day trader and usually holds his positions between 10 minutes and two hours. He does not trade the future directly, though, but zero-DTE options on the S&P 500. “I personally find it much more comfortable to enter my trades in the zero-DTE markets in the S&P,” he says, “and it gives me more advantages when it comes to time decay.”

The screen layout in the talk: at the top left, the zero-DTE gammaOne of the so-called Greeks in options trading that influence the hedging activity of market makers. chart, next to it the zero-DTE charmOne of the so-called Greeks in options trading that influence the hedging activity of market makers. chart. Below are the charts for the actual trading decisions: the zero-DTE chart and the cumulative version. On the right is the vanna exposure for the next five trading days including today, also individually and cumulatively. At the bottom, two new Volland widgets have been added, whose results are to be evaluated over the coming weeks.

04

The daily plan: the overnight session first

The first analysis of the day happens in the overnight session, and not only because of the Dubai location. “In my experience, the overnight session provides an extremely reliable outlook on the daily biasThe basic direction with which you go into the trading day.,” says Oliver Sparing. The base analysis rests solely on the data before the open; during the day, you watch how the exposure develops.

The exposure charts are read for four features.

  • Unusually high exposure Strikes with unusually high exposure can act like magnets or levels of interest. At these prices, it pays to look specifically into the order book and the order flow for possible entries.
  • Shift over time How the exposure shifts over time only becomes important in the cash session.
  • Outer boundaries This is where significant exposure ends. The curves used to be clearly narrower there and have become wider over the last few weeks.
  • Connected vanna clusters They form bull and bear zones, more on that in the next section.

The outer boundaries can be treated as a kind of expected move boundary, especially with zero DTE. In the example shown, the exposure drops abruptly below the 6,750 strike, in both the zero-DTE gamma chart and the vanna chart. From this, one can assume that informed market participants traded options mainly up to these strikes, and based on the current data it appears relatively unlikely that price will move beyond that range. These overnight boundaries are marked as strong “lines in the sand” on the chart. The working assumption behind this: when price reaches these areas, it usually meets support or resistance, depending on the situation and the context.

Six Volland charts for the SPX: top row zero-DTE gamma, zero-DTE charm and vanna for the next five trading days; bottom row zero-DTE vanna and the cumulative vanna curves. Green bars show positive, red bars negative exposure per strike.
Oliver’s Volland view of the example day: top left zero-DTE gamma, bottom left zero-DTE vanna. Below 6,750 the exposure drops off in both charts. From minute 20:30. Image: Wizard of Ops / Volland Refined
05

Vanna clusters: bull and bear zones

“My most important filters are the connected vanna clusters,” says Oliver Sparing. Internally, they are called vanna bull zones and vanna bear zones; the terms are not entirely precise in every market environment.

The logic behind them, using the example of a green zone above price: if customers sell calls there, dealers end up long out-of-the-money calls, and to hedge their delta, they sell the underlying. This creates positive vanna exposure. Vanna describes how delta changes when implied volatility changes. With a stable spot-vol relationshipThe relationship between price and implied volatility: in the large stock indices, volatility usually falls when price rises., volatility should fall as price rises. The delta of the calls then falls, the dealer has to scale back their hedge, and because this position is short, they buy back. That has a bullish effect and makes it easier for the market to rise.

Other Greeks also play a role, and the spot-vol relationship is not always intact. TradeNeon’s own statistical evaluations over the years nevertheless show a strong correlation between bull zones and rising prices and between bear zones and falling prices. The video gives no numbers for this.

Icon of the dealer hedging course
Dealer hedging course
Understand dealer hedging from the ground up
Learn about options, the Greeks and how possible hedging areas are calculated. The course uses examples from options, stocks and futures. It is currently taught in German.
Explore the course in German
06

Example: S&P and Nasdaq futures from the previous day

This example shows the analysis of a single day, not a general rule for price. On the previous day's S&P 500 future (ES) chart, the market first rotated around the weekly VWAPVolume weighted average price: the volume-weighted average price within a time period. at the start of the cash session, then price rose. As it ran into the red bear zone, implied volatility fell because of the rising prices. Because negative vanna sat above price, dealers sold in this reading, and resistance formed. From the zones, it could be inferred that the market would not run much further after breaking above the previous day's high. On that day, the overnight levels held.

Five-minute chart of the S&P 500 E-mini future with coloured vanna zones and a volume profile: price trades low for a long time, then rises steeply into the red zone at the top, where it moves sideways.
S&P 500 future (ES) on the example day: after the rotation, price rises into the red bear zone and makes little further progress. From minute 24:19. Image: Wizard of Ops / Volland Refined

The edges of the zones are of particular interest. In the previous day's Nasdaq future (NQ), price ran into the red bear zone in the pre-session and was sold through it. At the lower edge, price found support, and the market turned exactly at the CME SPANThe CME's risk measurement method, from which the recommended initial margin for futures also derives. risk interval. A rule of thumb, not a fixed rule: once the market has crossed a zone completely, it often runs back through the same zone in the opposite direction on the same day or shortly after, as here in the NQ future.

Five-minute chart of the Nasdaq 100 E-mini future with vanna zones: price falls through the dark red zone, turns at its lower edge near a blue line and then rises back through the same zone.
Nasdaq future (NQ) on the example day: price runs down through the red bear zone, turns at its lower edge, where the cursor points to the blue CME SPAN level, and runs back through the same zone. From minute 25:12. Image: Wizard of Ops / Volland Refined

The sequence in short: first the lines in the sand are marked, a daily bias is built, and in the overnight session it is decided what and where to trade. When the market approaches a level, possible entries are checked in the order book according to this plan. If the vanna shifts during the day, the live data counts, and the plan is adapted.

07

Tracking the boundaries during the day

The outer boundaries of vanna and charm are drawn into the chart roughly every 30 minutes, and that alone shows a lot about the shift in dynamics. An example: the market moves in a range, and the boundaries of the vanna exposure are close together. If the upper boundary then moves up clearly without the market following right away: “That is a strong bullish sign for me,” says Oliver Sparing. If price then breaks through a level, it is worth checking the order flow for a pullback to the breakout level.

Shifts in these boundaries can be a useful pointer to market moves about to come. Conditions have also changed recently: the vanna range has become wider, while charm and gamma have become narrower in comparison.

08

The week sets the room to move

In swing trading, Oliver mainly trades commodities. There, he keeps an eye on the vanna exposure of the coming week. It does not determine which direction he trades, but how much room he gives his trades. If the weekly chart fits what the zero-DTE data show, he holds trades clearly longer and builds positions over time. If the two contradict each other, for example bullish in zero DTE and bearish in the weekly chart, he takes shorter trades and manages them more actively.

That is the topic of the talk in a nutshell: different expirations provide different information, and only their interplay shows how much room a trade has.

09

Questions and conversation

In the conversation with the hosts, the topic also comes up of how dealer hedging data behave for options on futures. The hosts point out differences, for example that crude oil futures have monthly expirations and that statements for the first month cannot simply be transferred to later months. The guest mainly asks questions on this.

From the chat comes the question of whether dealers hedge their positions in the futures market instead of in the zero-DTE options. One of the hosts confirms it: dealers hedge options on the S&P 500 with the ES future. First, though, dealers try to get rid of their inventory, for example through corresponding prices. Oliver agrees: that is what futures are made for.

10

What you can take away from the talk

  • The time horizon determines the data. As a day trader, you look at different expirations than someone holding positions over days. The chart with all expirations shows higher sums but is not necessarily the right one.
  • Four features are in focus. Strikes with high exposure, their shift over time, the outer boundaries of the distribution and connected vanna clusters.
  • A plan before the open. Levels and bias take shape in the overnight session, and at the level the order book gets a close look.
  • The data are pointers, not certainties. Other Greeks and the spot-vol relationship play a part, and markets change. That is why the plan adapts to the live data.

“In my experience, it is extremely important for traders to look at the hedging data that is truly relevant for their own trading horizon, meaning the data that has the greatest effect in that time frame.”

Oliver Sparing at Volland Refined
11

About the talk

The talk ran on November 12, 2025 at Volland Refined, an all-day live event by Volland with several conversations, and is on the YouTube channel Wizard of Ops. Volland provides data on the positioning of options dealers. You can find more appearances on our guest appearances page. A basic introduction to the topic is given by the article Dealer Hedging: How It Works.

Level of Interest
Where do dealer hedging levels sit?
Level of Interest draws dealer hedging levels into your chart as potential price areas. You assess how the market trades there.
Explore Level of Interest
Frequently asked questions
Which expirations matter for day traders?

That depends on your own time horizon. One possible setup is the zero-DTE data, supplemented by the vanna exposure of the next five trading days including today; that is how Oliver Sparing works, who holds positions between 10 minutes and two hours. A chart with all expirations shows higher sums but also depicts forces that can count less directly for trading within a single day.

Why do market makers have to trade faster with zero DTE?

If an option expires on the same day, the market maker has to hedge their delta today. With an option that only expires in two weeks, they do not have to trade as fast and aggressively.

What are vanna bull and bear zones?

That is what connected areas of positive or negative vanna exposure are called, in which rising or falling prices tend to be expected. The terms do not apply exactly in every market environment, and other influences play a part.

Do dealers hedge options on the S&P 500 with the ES future?

Yes, that is what futures are made for. First, though, dealers try to get rid of their inventory through corresponding prices.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances

Dark Pools in Trading: What the Data Shows

Dark Pools in Trading: What the Data Shows

A dark pool of water in a vaulted hall: heavy stone blocks lie beneath the surface, and only ripples are visible on top.
VideoATAS webinar

Dark Pools in Trading:
What the Data Shows

Many large orders are executed on trading venues without a public order book. Dark pools are regulated, their trades are reported with a delay, and the data shows price and volume but not direction. This article explains what dark pools are, what their data reveals and how dark pool levels in crude oil and S&P 500 futures can be factored into trading plans.

Large orders stay below the surface. They only become visible later, through the traces they leave.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

Dark pools are regulated, private trading venues where institutions execute large orders without showing them in the public order book. Trades are reported with a delay. The data shows price and volume, but not whether the trade was a buy or a sell. As a level on the chart, it is a starting point for watching the order book, not an entry on its own.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 11

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: ATAS DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

What dark pools are

Dark pools are private trading venues. They exist alongside public exchanges such as the NYSE, but without a public order book and without real-time quotes. They emerged in the 1980s to execute large orders discreetly. They are usually operated by large banks and fund companies.

The name sounds like a shadow exchange. That image is wrong: dark pools are regulated, and every trade executed there has to be reported to the authorities.

03

Why institutions trade in dark pools

A hedge fund that wants to buy 10,000 ES contracts cannot send that order to the public order book as a market order. It would move the price against itself. Large market participants therefore split their orders and bring them into the market as inconspicuously as possible.

In a dark pool, buys and sells are matched algorithmically at the midpoint price, known as midpoint matchingBuys and sells are matched at the midpoint between the best bid and the best ask.. This reduces slippageThe difference between the expected price of an order and the price at which it is actually executed. and protects against front-runningOther market participants trade ahead of a detected large order to profit from its impact.: a large limit order in the public book would be spotted by algorithms, and the market might turn away from it beforehand. For retail traders, the downside is lower transparency. They have no direct access to dark pools.

04

What the data shows and what it does not

Operators report trades after execution with a delay, in the US usually within ten seconds, in some cases only on the next day. In Europe, trades often only have to be reported after 24 hours. At the latest by the following day, you can see as a retail trader, too, at what price level and in what volume large orders were executed.

Such a printThe report of an executed trade, with price, volume and time. does not reveal whether the trade was a buy or a sell. Every trade has a buyer and a seller. The intent also remains open: not every institutional trader is speculating. Some hedge positions, rebalance a portfolio or trade for tax reasons.

On its own, dark pool data is not enough. It gains weight only in combination with other factors, such as dealer hedging data or the CME's SPAN data. “With dark pool data in particular, it is very important to always combine it with other factors and generate an edge from that,” says Oliver Sparing. Access comes from delayed, publicly available FINRA reports and paid data platforms. In our software Level of Interest, we analyze the data every morning and draw the dark pool levels we consider relevant directly onto the chart.

05

Two examples from the ATAS replay

Two situations from the same week, recorded with the replay function of ATAS and the order book heatmapThe heatmap shows the order book over time: where limit orders sat and how large they were., show how a dark pool level can be observed in practice.

Crude oil future (CL)

On the previous day, an unusually large order had traded in a dark pool below the previous day's low, and the market rose afterwards. The assumption: a larger buyer had positioned there. When price came back into the zone, the order book showed large limit orders at the dark pool level and at the settlement priceThe official settlement price of a futures contract at the end of the trading day. above it. Both were filled, new buy orders kept arriving below the level, and price eventually broke out above the settlement price.

In this situation, the settlement price sat as resistance above the level. Had a setup formed close to that resistance, the trade would have had little room in the intended direction, and then this applies: “If there is resistance right in front of me, I do well to be patient and not enter the trade prematurely,” says Oliver Sparing.

Order book heatmap of the crude oil future in the ATAS replay: bright horizontal lines show large limit orders, and price runs down into that area.
Crude oil future (CL) in the ATAS replay: the heatmap shows large limit orders as bright lines. Still from the webinar, minute 37. Image: ATAS Deutschland

S&P 500 future (ES)

Here, three levels sat at one price: the settlement price, the previous day's low and a dark pool level. Such a coincidence counts as a level with triple confirmation. The market bounced off it twice. The second time, the heatmap first showed a stop runPrice moves through a zone where many stop orders sit and triggers them. below the level before price broke out to the upside. “I love levels with triple confirmation. There is nothing better than when several factors coincide and tell us: there is institutional interest,” says Oliver.

5-minute chart of the S&P 500 future with volume profile: price falls back to the same price area twice and then rises.
S&P 500 future (ES): the market comes back to the level twice before breaking out to the upside. Still from the webinar, minute 49. Image: ATAS Deutschland

A level that reacts does not make a trade by itself. “Not just placing a limit order somehow and a stop five ticks below, that will not work, but always working with clear, repeatable setups,” says Oliver Sparing.

06

What you can take away from the webinar

  • A level is a place, not a trade. Before the session, you decide in your market analysis where you will look for long or short trades. At the level, the order book then decides.
  • Levels also help with waiting. If the next resistance is only a few ticks away, it can be worth waiting for the breakout so the trade has more room in your direction. If many levels sit close together, it can make sense to skip the area altogether.
  • No blanket limit orders at levels. The market can run through a level by a few ticks and still react to it.
  • A setup has to be repeatable. What matters is a pattern you recognize clearly and evaluate statistically with your trading journal.

“None of this is the holy grail of trading.”

Oliver Sparing on dark pool levels and dealer hedging data (translated from the German webinar)
07

About the webinar

The webinar ran on October 30, 2025 as part of the webinar series on the YouTube channel of ATAS Deutschland, hosted by Pavel from ATAS. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on automatically translated subtitles. ATAS is a trading platform for order flow analysis. Oliver is a regular guest there; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Free Plan · Dark Pool Profile
Where did trading happen off the exchange?
The Dark Pool Profile shows you the aggregated dark pool volume of the last two US trading days over the 5-minute chart of the latest session. It is part of TradeNeon's Free Plan.
Start Free Plan
Frequently asked questions
Are dark pools legal?

Yes. Dark pools are regulated trading venues, usually operated by large banks or fund companies. Every trade executed there is reported to the authorities, although with a delay.

Can I trade in dark pools as a retail trader?

No, retail traders have no direct access. You can, however, analyze the reported trades once they are published.

Does a dark pool print show whether it was a buy or a sell?

No. A print shows price and volume. Who took the initiative and what intent lies behind it remains open. That is why context matters: how did the market move afterwards, and what does the order book show when price comes back to the level?

Which timeframe suits the heatmap?

For the heatmap and microstructure, a very short timeframe is the usual choice, such as a 5-second chart. A 5-minute chart is common for the course of the day, and an hourly or 4-hour chart for the bigger picture. Between comparable timeframes, such as 1 minute or 5 minutes, the picture usually changes only slightly.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances

Level of Interest: Automated Market Analysis

Level of Interest: Automated Market Analysis

Nasdaq future on a 5-minute chart: the Level of Interest price areas spread across the trading day from left to right.
VideoATAS webinar

Level of Interest:
The market analysis
behind the levels

Every morning, the levels are drawn onto the chart by hand and cross-checked against the order book. The software Level of Interest grew out of that routine and brings these levels into your own charting software. This article tells how it came about, which seven data areas feed into the analysis and how the levels can be used in trading.

The same session, once without and once with the levels that are set before trading begins.Chart: TradeNeon

Key points first

Level of Interest draws levels onto the chart that are derived by hand every morning from seven data areas, including dealer hedging, dark pool data, volume and market profile, VWAPs and the CME's SPAN data. The levels are cross-checked against the order book and are not changed during the day. They show where it is worth looking closely but a reaction is never certain.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 20

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: ATAS DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

How Level of Interest came about

Oliver has traded for many years, first swing trading and commodities, later day trading as well. On a trading floor in London, he learned that a market analysis is part of every professional trading session's preparation. It can be very multilayered, and there is no single way to do it. His own analysis has developed considerably over the years: today he draws on a large number of data sources, evaluates them every morning and uses them to build a plan for the entire trading day.

The training programme raised the question of how participants can check their own analysis. So a screenshot of the levels was posted on the Discord server every morning. Participants drew in their own levels and compared them with these. At some point, people asked to see the levels in their own charting software. That was the start of Level of Interest. Together with the development team, a very basic version was built first. Later, TradeNeon decided to offer the levels to traders outside the training programme as well and to build the tool on a more professional footing.

03

Levels set in the morning, unchanged all day

Transparency was the goal from the start. The analysis was posted as a screenshot, and the next morning a second one followed with the full price action of the day. That way, anyone can judge for themselves whether price reacted to the levels or not.

A firm rule goes with this: the levels drawn in the morning are “set in stone.” They are not changed during the day, and the same applies to Level of Interest as software.

04

The seven areas of the analysis

Seven areas feed into the analysis.

  • Dealer hedging This calculates where dealer hedgingOption dealers hedge the risk from options trading by buying and selling in the underlying market, which influences price. is especially strong and in which areas market makers mainly have to buy or mainly have to sell. This is where the bullish and bearish hedging levels come from.
  • Fibonacci retracements Classic Fibonacci retracementsA chart analysis tool that derives price levels from a previous price move. give levels that price can still react to in 2025. They are drawn by hand, cross-checked against current order book data and only set if they are relevant at that moment.
  • Dark pool data Large orders in the dark poolA private exchange where large orders are traded away from the official exchange. Trades are reported afterwards. are reported at the end of the day. They show at which price levels and in what size large positions were traded, but not who traded or whether it was long or short.
  • Volume and market profile The volume profileShows how much was traded at which price levels. and the market profile show where fair price areas were and where price moved quickly. Combined with the order book, they mark areas where institutional participants have built large positions.
  • Liquidity in the order book The limit orders in the order book are the foundation: every level should be confirmed by liquidity clusters. Historical extremes are added to this.
  • VWAPs The VWAPVolume Weighted Average Price: the volume-weighted average price over a period. shows the average price paid in the market over a period of time and is a reference point for who controls the trend. In addition, the VWAPs of the previous day, week and month are drawn when they sit in a relevant price area.
  • The CME's SPAN data The CME's SPANThe CME's risk assessment method, from which the recommended initial margin for futures is derived. method provides the daily risk assessment. From it, TradeNeon calculates a price range starting from the previous day's close, with strong reactions often to be expected at its edge.

The aim is to look at the market from as many perspectives as possible and to build a comprehensive picture of where institutional interest sits on the chart. When several factors coincide, such as a strong dealer hedging level lining up with a dark pool level, several data sources point to the same spot. You can find tutorials on all seven areas in the Level of Interest tutorials.

05

Dealer hedging: bullish and bearish levels

Whoever buys or sells an option usually has a market makerA market participant that provides liquidity to the market and takes the other side of trades in return. on the other side of the trade, a so-called option dealer. The dealer's job is to provide liquidity to the market so that you get filled quickly, at your price and without a wide spread. The business model is not to speculate against you: the dealer tries to pass the trade on to the other side of the order book right away at a small profit. If that fails, a directional risk remains, which the dealer neutralizes by buying or selling the underlying. In doing so, the dealer moves the price. This hedging is dynamic: it depends on price direction, volatility and time, and has to be adjusted continuously.

Level of Interest calculates where this hedging is particularly strong and in which areas market makers mainly have to buy or mainly have to sell. These are the green and red levels as well as the large green and red zones at the edge of the chart. TradeNeon does not take data over statically but interprets it and does its own calculations.

Besides gammaOne of the so-called Greeks in options trading that influence the hedging activity of market makers., TradeNeon includes vannaOne of the so-called Greeks in options trading that influence the hedging activity of market makers. and charmOne of the so-called Greeks in options trading that influence the hedging activity of market makers.. That is why TradeNeon calls them bullish and bearish hedging levels, not gamma, vanna or charm levels. The assumption behind this: when the market reaches such a level, market makers have to lean towards buying or towards selling. Price does not always have to rise from a bullish level, though. Hedging activity is only one part of the market, and other participants have their own agenda. “Of course we cannot promise that every bullish hedging level sends price shooting up and every bearish one sends it down,” says Oliver.

Converting between related markets calls for care. Carrying a level from the SPX or the SPY over to the ES at a fixed mathematical distance often does not work well, because the relationship is dynamic. That is why TradeNeon cross-checks the levels against order book data and against volume and market profile data.

06

Fibonacci, dark pool data and the order book

Fibonacci retracements

Almost every common charting platform has Fibonacci tools, and in 2025 price still reacts to certain levels. What matters is how they are used: “In my opinion, it is not necessarily useful to draw Fibonacci retracements at random in trending phases and go long or short at the 50 level. You have to know how to combine Fibonacci concepts with other data to arrive at the levels that really have some relevance,” says Oliver Sparing. TradeNeon draws all levels by hand and cross-checks them against current order book data. If a level has no relevance at the moment, it is not drawn. Ideally, that avoids a “jungle” of levels on the chart.

Dark pool data

Dark pools are private exchanges where traders with deep pockets can route orders past the official exchange. That sounds like a conspiracy theory, but it is more transparent than people think: in the US, traders have to disclose their positions traded in dark pools to the US regulator at the end of the day. You do not see who traded, or whether it was long or short, but you do see at which price levels and in what size large positions were traded. The background: large market participants want to bring their orders into the market gradually, without moving the price against themselves. TradeNeon also cross-checks this data against the order book and provides it as dark pool levels.

Volume and market profile, liquidity

Volume and market profile are part of a day trader's standard toolkit today. They show where fair price areas were, where price moved quickly and where the premium and discount areas of an auction were. TradeNeon combines this data with the order book to mark areas where institutional participants have built large positions and that will probably be defended if the market comes back. Large round prices come on top, as they are important levels by nature.

Liquidity, meaning the limit orders in the order book, is the foundation: every level should be confirmed by liquidity clusters. Not every limit order is relevant, though. That is why the order book is always included, to see exactly where institutional interest lies.

07

VWAPs and the SPAN interval

The VWAP shows the average price paid in the market over a period of time. An example: if a fund manager wants to build a larger position over several days in an uptrend, the moment the market comes back to the trend's VWAP is the most favorable time to buy, before the average long position slips into a loss. That is why VWAPs are reference points for who controls the trend, and they can be strong resistance and support zones. In addition, TradeNeon draws the VWAP of the previous day, the previous week and the previous month when they sit in a relevant price area. If price is above the previous day's closing VWAP, the average long position from that day is in profit. That is important information but not the holy grail. Many partial aspects count toward the day's biasThe basic direction with which you enter the trading day..

The CME, the largest futures exchange in the world, provides the SPAN data every day. The SPAN framework is used to simulate portfolio risk and contains the daily risk assessment from which the recommended initial margin is derived. On that basis, and starting from the previous day's close, TradeNeon calculates a price range showing how far price can run before institutional traders come under pressure and receive margin callsA demand to add funds or reduce positions when the collateral is too low..

The interval has two advantages. Institutional traders have an interest in keeping price within this interval, so strong reactions are often to be expected at its edge. If the market breaks out of the interval, however, participants have to adjust, buy more or reduce positions, and volatility can rise rapidly. For beginners, this means: “If you are a day trading beginner, concentrate on trades inside the SPAN interval at first, because the market behaves more rationally there and reacts better to our levels,” says Oliver. The analysis itself is accordingly not drawn far beyond the interval.

08

Questions from the chat: levels during the day

On the settlement price: it is the settlement price of the previous day as set by the exchange, the market often reacts to it, and it plays into the day's bias. As a rule of thumb, the tendency is more bullish above the settlement price and more bearish below it.

On whether a level that price has already run into should be ignored from then on: “yes and no.” If the market rotates around a level and no longer respects it, you should not take trades there for the time being. If the market moves further away from the level and comes back later, experience shows that a reaction is to be expected again, even though that is a discretionary assessment. “There are moments when I say: the market obviously has no interest in this level anymore, so I keep my hands off. But the same level can offer a really good entry opportunity at a later point,” says Oliver.

On the pre-session: the levels are calculated mainly from what happened in the cash sessions, because that is where most of the trading takes place. In his experience, they work just as well in the pre-session. On the exchange holiday that the webinar fell on, there were no levels, because no institutional trading took place.

09

Interpretation instead of raw data

Level of Interest is not a pure data provider. The slogan is “See what matters”: TradeNeon draws on many data sources, evaluates them and draws the result onto the chart. Every morning, a manually produced market analysis is created that rests on many years of experience. It is based on data, but further factors feed in as well, to place each level as precisely as possible where it belongs.

Oliver himself is a discretionary order book trader and uses the levels for that. Level of Interest, however, can be combined with any existing system, and very different approaches can be developed on the basis of the levels. One approach for developing a system based on the levels was presented in the ATAS webinar on backtesting.

Raw data alone decides little: what matters is what the trader makes of it. With Level of Interest, the point is therefore to draw onto the chart what has practical value.

10

Level of Interest in ATAS

Level of Interest is a plugin for ATAS, in other words an indicator. You place it in your indicator folder as usual and load it in any chart. You enter the license key in the indicator settings and then have access to the levels of the markets you have subscribed to. The labels of the levels can be switched on and off in the indicator settings. The software also runs on other platforms; you can find the overview on the Level of Interest page.

11

What you can take away from the webinar

  • Market analysis is the foundation of preparation. Every session starts with a plan derived from many data sources. The levels are drawn before the open.
  • Several perspectives give a fuller picture. Areas where different data sources meet deserve particular attention, such as a hedging level with a dark pool level.
  • A level is a place, not a certainty. A reaction is never certain. The order book belongs with every level because it shows precisely where institutional interest lies.
  • Traceability builds trust. Levels that are fixed in the morning and not changed during the day can be compared with price action by you, every day.

“Data is only ever as meaningful and as powerful as the trader who uses, evaluates and interprets it.”

Oliver Sparing in the ATAS webinar (translated from German)
12

About the webinar

The webinar ran on June 19, 2025 as part of the webinar series on the YouTube channel of ATAS Deutschland. In this series, ATAS presents external developments and tools that work with the platform. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on automatically translated subtitles. ATAS is a trading platform for order flow analysis. Oliver is a regular guest there; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Level of Interest
Which levels deserve a closer look?
Level of Interest helps you find potential price areas for analysis. You assess how the market trades when it reaches them.
Explore Level of Interest
Frequently asked questions
What is Level of Interest?

Level of Interest is software from TradeNeon that draws levels onto the chart. The levels are derived by hand every morning from seven data areas, including dealer hedging, dark pool data, volume and market profile, VWAPs and the CME's SPAN data, and cross-checked against the order book.

Are the levels adjusted during the day?

No. The levels drawn in the morning are “set in stone” and are not changed during the day. That way, you can check every day whether price reacted to them.

Should I ignore a level if price has already run into it?

Not across the board. If the market rotates around a level and no longer respects it, you should not take trades there for the time being. If the market has moved further away and comes back later, experience shows that a reaction is to be expected again, even though that is a discretionary assessment.

Do I have to trade Level of Interest with a specific system?

No. The levels can be combined with any existing system, and very different approaches can be developed on their basis. They originally came about for discretionary order book trading.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances

Backtesting in Day Trading: Testing a Trading Idea with Data

Backtesting in Day Trading: Testing a Trading Idea with Data

An old film viewer on an editing table, with strips of film laid out in even rows in front of it and blank index cards and film cans beside it.
VideoATAS webinar

Backtesting in Day Trading:
Testing a Trading Idea
with Data

If you trade discretionarily, you make the decision yourself in the moment, and even so, the trading idea behind it needs a foundation of data. A backtest for discretionary day traders has two steps: first a statistical test with fixed rules in replay, then the discretionary execution. Here the process is walked through using the S&P 500 future in the ATAS replay.

The same idea, played through again and again and filed neatly. Only the quantity makes a statement possible.Image: TradeNeon

Key points first

A statistical backtest comes before discretionary trading: with clear rules that leave no room for interpretation, trades are collected in replay and recorded in a table with entry, result, maximum open profit and maximum open loss. After about 30 to 50 trades, a first feel emerges for whether the idea is heading in the right direction; 300 trades count as a “golden amount” for a first statistical statement, a value from experience rather than proof of a lasting edge. The table gives indications of where stops and position size might need adjusting, and the example shown is explicitly not a finished trading system.

01

The video

Playing the video connects to YouTube. Watch on YouTube

Chapters in the video 17

Click a timestamp to start the video at that point.

Video: ATAS DeutschlandMore videos from TradeNeon on our YouTube channel.

02

Why a statistical backtest comes first

There are two kinds of backtests. The statistical backtest comes first, even if you intend to trade discretionarily later. It answers a preliminary question: is the basic idea your trading system is meant to rest on heading in the right direction at all, and can an edgeA recurring advantage in the market that holds up over many trades and after costs and does not rest on chance. A backtest offers indications of it, not proof. be developed from it?

This calls for fixed rules. Unlike later in discretionary trading, they must leave no room for interpretation: if the market does this and this, it is an entry. If it does that and that, it is an exit, whether a stop, a certain market move or a span of time. The decisions in discretionary trading should still rest on market logic and a repeatable core idea later on. In the end, it always comes down to pattern recognition: you need something you can recognize and repeat.

03

Market analysis as the foundation of the trading idea

Before any backtest comes the question of where you want to trade in the first place. It starts with a market analysis: at which prices does institutional trading interest sit? Which factors do you include, such as volume profile, market profile, the footprint chartA chart that shows, inside each candle, how much was bought and sold at which prices., VWAP, dealer hedging data or dark pool data? Oliver Sparing works with his own levels from this analysis, available as the software Level of Interest. They are the basis for every system he develops.

When the market reaches one of these levels, it is already settled whether a trade is considered there and in which direction. Then a specific pattern is needed that has to be visible before buying or selling. Which data you use is your decision. “I personally consider level 2 data the biggest advantage you can have as a retail day trader, and I would not want to miss that data. But I am the last person to say that trading is not possible without level 2 data,” says Oliver Sparing, who trades the order book himself.

04

Using the replay properly

To collect the data, the replayThe playback of past market data in ATAS, which lets you practice and test as in live trading. function in ATAS is a good fit. “The replay function is your most powerful tool, especially when you are at the start of your trading career,” says Oliver Sparing. As of May 2025, the replay data, including order book data, came directly from ATAS. To practice and learn, you therefore did not need a paid live data feed from the beginning. Level 2 data is needed for the heatmapThe heatmap shows the order book over time: where limit orders sat and how large they were. in real-time use. ATAS now offers several replay modes with different data depth, and real-time data and replay are two different things. Which data your replay contains today, you are best off checking directly with ATAS.

Two warnings apply to the replay. First, speed: anyone who tests the strategy at a hundred times the speed takes the psychology out of trading, and psychology is exactly what often causes the biggest problems later. At points where a trade could come up, five times speed at most is advisable, preferably two times or real time. In fast-forward, sitting out a sideways phase costs no effort. In real time, the same phase drags on for twenty minutes and tests your patience.

Second, trading hours: you do not sit at the market twenty-four hours a day. So backtest only the time window in which you can actually trade in everyday life. Even if you see a good opportunity shortly before or after, it does not belong in the statistics, because in real time you would probably not have traded it.

05

The example idea: structure at a level

As an example, take a day in the S&P 500 future when the market sits in a bear zone, an area from the Level of Interest analysis. Bear zones and bull zones serve as part of the daily orientation and as a filter: in bear zones the focus is mainly on short trades, in bull zones mainly on long trades. Oliver Sparing trades this way in about 90 percent of his trades. There are exceptions, which are not covered here.

5-minute chart of the S&P 500 future on May 22, 2025 with a bear zone shaded in red. Overnight the price moves sideways between a purple-pink line and a volume profile level at 5,876, drops sharply shortly before the open down to the lower edge of the bear zone and bounces up from there.
The trading day on the 5-minute chart: the bear zone (shaded red) comes from the Level of Interest analysis and is derived from dealer hedging data. From minute 21:20. Image: ATAS Deutschland

The day unfolds like this: in the Asian and European sessions, the market moves sideways between the previous day's settlement price and a volume profile level at 5,876. Shortly before the open, it sells off sharply, runs down to the lower edge of the bear zone and bounces up from there almost exactly.

The rule for the test is kept deliberately plain. On the 5-second chart, the market runs into a level and forms a small structure. As soon as it makes a lower low, meaning it undercuts the last low, the test opens a short trade. In the bull zone, the reverse applies for long trades. The stop sits above the last high. If the trade moves in the desired direction, the stop is trailed above the last high with every new lower low. The trade ends when the market breaks that high to the upside.

An important point: this is not a finished trading system and not a recommendation to trade it this way. It is a coherent core idea from which a system can be developed. Money and risk management and position size play no role yet in the first, purely statistical pass. The calculation is done without slippage, and for the stop, the first aim is to find out in which range it should sit for this idea.

06

The evaluation table

The data belongs in a plain table. A professional trading journal looks different, as we show in our article How to Keep a Trading Journal. For a statistical backtest, five values are enough.

  • Date and time You record when the trade took place, in the example in New York time.
  • Direction You note whether the trade was long or short.
  • Result in ticks The result is recorded in ticksThe smallest price step of a futures contract. The result of a trade is often measured in ticks., even if the trade was stopped out.
  • Maximum open profit This is how far the trade moved in your direction before it ended.
  • Maximum open loss This is how far the trade moved against you after entry. This value is especially important.

The entry and exit price should also be noted. Partial profits that you take later in discretionary trading are entered separately in the table.

07

Two examples in replay

In the replay, two trades play out following this logic, both on the same trading day (May 22, 2025), the second at the previous day's settlement price and further levels. In the first case, the trade ends after a short time at the trailed stop, although in the course of it, it had been well further in profit. In the second case, the market runs through several levels in the desired direction, the stop is trailed several times, and the trade only ends at the trailed stop.

TradeResultMax. open profitMax. open loss
Trade 1 · 9:15 a.m. NY · short+1 tick+29 ticks−2 ticks
Trade 2 · 10:10 a.m. NY · short+63 ticks+121 ticks−4 ticks

These are two illustrative examples from the replay of May 22, 2025, calculated without slippage and costs. They are no proof of performance of the idea or of any strategy. The first trade shows how far the course of a trade and its result can lie apart: at one point it stood 29 ticks in open profit and ended at one tick. A stop of three ticks would have been enough to stay in the trade, because such a small open loss is rather unusual at this point.

5-second chart of the S&P 500 future with an order book heatmap in replay. A measuring box shaded in red spans from the entry to the exit at the trailed stop, and its label shows 63 ticks (15.75 points).
The second trade in replay: the measuring box runs from the entry to the exit at the trailed stop and shows 63 ticks (15.75 points). From minute 45:40. Image: ATAS Deutschland

Here the difference between replay and practice becomes visible. In accelerated replay, everything feels comfortable. In a real trade that is well in profit, your finger would probably often itch to take profits. “That ‘this is enough for me now’ is the end of every profitable trading system. If you take profits on a gut feeling, that is never good,” says Oliver Sparing. The statistical test, by contrast, deals with a purely mechanical idea that shows what the market actually offers in relation to the trading idea.

08

Evaluating many trades: 300 as a figure from experience

A sensible assignment is to evaluate at least 300 such trades. That is a lot of work, but it gives you a good feel for the market. The numbers are values from experience, not universal thresholds. After about 30 to 50 trades, a first feel emerges for whether the idea is heading in the right direction. If it turns out that there are almost only big losers and hardly any winners, the idea probably has no potential. If it is heading in the right direction, it is worth continuing. “300 trades are always a kind of golden amount, where you can really make a statistical statement about whether a system has potential,” says Oliver Sparing. That is not proof of a viable edge, and a historical test does not predict future results.

Even though it is tedious in practice, anyone who keeps the table up to date every day and has evaluated 300 trades usually knows the market much better and can make clearer decisions later.

09

What the statistics reveal about stops and position size

The table reveals a fair amount. Two examples: If it turns out that, on average, the trades run much further into open profit than what is left in the end, you are probably giving back too much profit. In discretionary trading, you then need to work on your stop placement, without taking away the room the trade needs and damaging the hit rate.

If, conversely, it turns out that winning trades rarely move far against you after entry, a much tighter stop would be conceivable. It might worsen the hit rate somewhat but sharply reduce the loss per trade. At the same time, position size could be scaled up. Evaluating the maximum values makes these relationships visible. The table gives indications here, for example for a tighter stop or a larger position size, but not yet proof that this adjustment works after costs and under other market conditions. Only the further test, the discretionary pass in the next section, shows that.

One more tip from practice: markets change, and a stop that is normal today can be too large or too small in half a year because volatility has changed. So do not shy away from larger stops if the market phase calls for them. With micro futuresSmaller versions of common futures with a fraction of the contract value, which allow position size to be adjusted more finely., you can reduce position size so that your risk per trade stays the same. How the risk per trade fits your account size, you work out with the contract's tick value: stop in ticks times tick value gives the risk per contract. In day trading, Oliver Sparing goes by 0.5 percent risk per trade; one percent is already too aggressive for him.

10

From the statistical to the discretionary backtest

If the first pass has shown that the idea has potential, the second part follows. You now trade the rules discretionarily and keep filling in the table, this time with the actual values: where would you have taken partial profits, where closed the rest of the position, how did the trade run under your management? On the basis of your stop, you choose the position size that fits your risk and enter the results. In the end, you see how the system performed under discretionary management.

In his own trading and in the day trading programme, far more factors interact: the order book, liquidity and its shifts, limit orders that come in or are pulled, the delta, the behavior of active market participants, price action, order flow events as well as market speed and auction speed. The example here is the core idea through which the process can be shown.

11

What you can take away from the webinar

  • Statistical first, then discretionary. Fixed rules with no room for interpretation show whether your idea is heading in the right direction at all.
  • The replay takes discipline. Test at a speed close to real time, and only in the time window in which you can actually trade.
  • Maximum open profit and open loss belong in the table. They give indications of where you give profits back and how tight a stop could be.
  • The amount of data counts. Around 300 evaluated trades are a figure from experience for a first statement about an idea's potential, not proof of an edge. Along the way, you get to know the market.

“Anyone who does not collect data will struggle to become profitable in the long run.”

Oliver Sparing on the statistical backtest (translated from German)
12

About the webinar

The webinar ran on May 29, 2025 on the YouTube channel of ATAS Deutschland and was hosted by ATAS. It is held in German; on YouTube, you can switch on machine-translated subtitles. ATAS is a trading platform for order flow analysis. Oliver is a regular guest there; you can find all appearances on our guest appearances page.

Day trading programme
How do you develop your own system?
In our day trading programme, you work on analysis, entries and risk management as one connected approach that fits your time and your temperament. The programme is currently offered in German.
Day trading programme (German)
Frequently asked questions
Why does a discretionary trader need a statistical backtest?

It shows whether your core idea is heading in the right direction at all and whether an edge can be developed from it. That only works with fixed rules that leave no room for interpretation. The discretionary execution follows afterwards.

How many trades should a backtest include?

There is no fixed number. Values from experience: after about 30 to 50 trades, a first feel emerges for whether the idea is heading in the right direction, and 300 trades count as a “golden amount” for a first statistical statement about the potential. These are not universal thresholds and no proof of a viable edge, and a historical test does not predict future results.

Which values belong in the evaluation table?

Date, time, direction, the result in ticks, the maximum open profit and the maximum open loss after entry. The entry and exit price should also be noted.

What should I watch for in the replay?

Choose the speed carefully: at points where a trade could come up, five times at most, preferably two times or real time, so that you keep a feel for the actual market speed. Also test only the time window in which you can actually trade in everyday life.

Oliver Sparing
Oliver Sparing
Founder & Head of Trading · TradeNeon
Oliver Sparing has been actively trading the financial markets since 2011. His professional roots lie in precious metals trading in Hamburg; in 2017 he learned at a London trading floor. At TradeNeon he leads the day trading and swing trading programmes and is responsible for the trading methodology, with a focus on order flow, market structure and fundamental market data. Level of Interest, Futures Insights and Lab of Trades grew out of this work. Platforms such as ATAS, Bookmap and WH SelfInvest regularly invite him as a guest. All guest appearances